Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Will a plecostomus algae eating fish live 60 days on just plain green algae in a 1 gallon bottle?
I have to create an ecosystem for Biology and I decided that I was going to put aquarium water in a 1 gallon Hawian Punch bottle and put a plecostomus in it. I collected green algae off the filter from my aquarium and put it in the water, hoping it would start to grow bacteria before I actually put the plecostomus fish in. Does anyone think that the fish will last 60 days for the project?
By the way... the bottle is sealed so I can't add or change anything once I have it done. I won't get disqualified for having a live animal in my experiment. That is the point of the experiment to see if we can keep it alive, without adding food such as algae wafers. Also, if I add algae wafers in now before I actually add the fish, will they dissolve and help more algae grow??? Thanks for all your help!!!
I have to have a TOTALLY sealed container. Don't ask me why because I have no idea... I just know that I can't have an air pump or anything. Also, I know this experiment sounds very cruel but we are REQUIRED to use a live animal. That's just the way the experiment is... Again... Thanks for all your input.
8 Answers
- Mommy to BoysLv 61 decade agoFavorite Answer
Never. This is cruel. Plecos only eat specific kinds of algae. The common misconception is that they eat any algae, but the truth is, most if it is to rich and thick for their lips. If you want to feed one, buy some algae pellets. My pleco is very spoiled and loves them! He wont eat much else. A 1 gallon bottle is also way too small for it. Not to mention that it will need cleaned out very well.
If you want something to put it in get at least a 2.5 gallon tank. They are about $25 at walmart. These are also easy to transport if you will be needing to take it to class. If nothing else get it one of those portable pet carriers. (one of the large ones!) This would at least house it for 60 days if you plan on putting it in your larger tank after the project is over. If you do get one of those though, you should get an air pump. If you can't manage this then you should consider not using a live animal.
Good luck on your project!
Edit: If you wont be able to feed it, then don't do it. The algae pellets don't promote algae growth. Most plecos actually thrive off of the food you feed your other fish. They are really bottom feeders, and not algae eaters. They just prefer algae. Personally, I've never had one that keep my tank algae free. Also, all fish need oxygen. If it is sealed you are giving the fish a 1 stop trip to fishy heaven. I would consider doing something with live aquarium plants. These can create their own oxygen from the water and you're not putting a helpless life in danger.
Edit 2: To be totally honest, your teacher needs to be reported to the school district for REQUIRING a live animal. This is wrong, because these animals aren't there for you to just experiment with. They are just trying to live their life and hoping that people will take care of them. A totally sealed container is going to kill ANY live animal if it can't get oxygen flow. It honestly wont even last a week, more less 60 days. There are no live creatures that live in this kind of environment naturally. I would talk to your parents and see what they think. You should honestly bring this up with the principal if not the school board. This is far from ethical on the teachers part.
- 1 decade ago
Nope, it will die pretty fast..
Plecos need, I'd say, a minimum of 40-55 Gallons of water, so 1 gallon won't do. They also need a heater and a filter, so a bottle won't do. It should also have a bit more then just some green algae in a bottle.
Sorry, but this is experiment, is a recipe for disaster, and you shouldn't do it. No fish will survive in that bottle, so you should probably think of a new experiment. From what I know, live animals in an experiment will get you disqualified, but maybe your rules are different.. Please, don't kill the innocent Pleco for an experiment that won't work...
By the way, are you even sure the bottle is 1 gallon? Because if it is a 1LITRE bottle, than that is even less than 1 gallon...
best of luck.
EDIT: Oh and I forgot, the bottle will give NO space for oxygen... just don't do it lol.. not a good idea. The first person isn't right at all btw. No fish could live in a bottle, not even a betta, and even a baby wouldn't make a difference for the project, it will just die...
- Anonymous1 decade ago
use a snail or shrimp and add like some live plants or somehting an put it in direct sunlight to get as much light as possible., the live plants are what's really neccisary for anything in there to live more than a few hours., you need alot of plants and one very small animal.
fill the bottle about 2/3 or 3/4 full so that air can exchange between the plants and the air in the bottle for the snail/shrimp to live on...
they do stuff like this all the time really they just need REALLY small organisms and lots of plants and stuff to feed the animal and oxygenate the water.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
no way
1. filtration(must have)
2. heat(needs a constant temp of around 77 degrees)
3. ammonia(enough to kill it in 24 hours)
4. oxygen
5. oxygen
EDIT...YOUR experiment may work with brine shrimp If you put in a plant called anacharis..as this may provide enough oxygen...It should work for your live animal...but the pleco is going to die within a day or two.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 1 decade ago
use something else, man, one gallon sealed off is not appropriate for a pleco. there are all sorts of other animals you can use that aren't fish. snails, for example, or brine shrimp.
- 1 decade ago
Get a small pleco. A very small one. Rinse out the bttle very well. and also get some hikari algea wafers and he should be good. Algea wafers are excelent for the pleco. make sure the water is good quality and a good temp since plecos are tropical fish of South America. And you should be good to go. Just make sure to do water changes. Plecos poop, a lot.
Source(s): Fish breeder and enthusiast - Anonymous1 decade ago
How about a tadpoles you could get a young one half fill it put loads of food in there and some fruit flys or something , still its pretty mean.