Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Just wondering...?
Could a batsmen get given out by the umpire without the fielding side appealing
17 Answers
- QuandaryLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
NO! He cannot be given out unless there is an appeal
He might walk but the umpire can (theoretically) call him back if there is no appeal. It is the umpire and only the umpire who decides. In practice no-one bothers with the obvious ones.
I actually had a clear run out at the bowler's end once when I was umpiring (it flicked the bowlers leg and hit the stumps while the non-striker was out of his ground). The batsman actually started to walk but there was no appeal. He stopped and still no appeal. He gave me a sheepish grin and kept batting.
Theoretically even if the stumps are knocked over clean bowled, unless there is an appeal, the batsman is entitled to stand his ground until there is an appeal and it is given out.
Source(s): Accredited umpire. - Anonymous1 decade ago
i'm pretty sure if it was an LBW, it would most definitely require some sort of shouting or hullabaloo. Caught behind is different- if it was totally obvious it was out, they'd just be like yay he's out. I've seen some players get all hyped up cos they knew it was definitely out and then look at the umpire and he's like nah bud sorry not out. then they get sad
hahahah sucked in ;)
good luck buddy!
- Nafeez NashLv 61 decade ago
No, he cannot be given OUT unless there is an appeal by the fielding side.
Cheers!
- Anonymous1 decade ago
If there's no appeal, the umpires can't give it out unless the batsman walks.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- DamoLv 51 decade ago
No, if the fielding team do not appeal the batter can not be given out... This happened in the recent test match between NZ n England
- Anonymous1 decade ago
yes, of course.
I mean..the fielding side never appeal for an obvious catch, say on the boundary for instance, do they? Everyone, including the batsman, knows its out and there's no argument.
- 1 decade ago
Good Question...that condition will not come..because all the players are young and the umpires are bit old..they cannot notice...the ball.
- feejuLv 41 decade ago
only if its a LBW decision
otherwise if the batsman is clearly out than he usually walks out of the ground without the bowling team appealing
Source(s): me - Anonymous1 decade ago
No,would you give someone out if the fielding side did not want to ask the question?
No me neither....
- Anonymous1 decade ago
there should have an appeal otherwise umpires fingers will not rise up.. no appeal, no out.