Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Grandfather in delivery room?

My questions is simple. Should the grandfather be in the delivery room?

I was there when my grandaughter was born (behind a make-shift "curtain" they made. I missed my oldest daughter's first born (it is still killing me), so I had to be there for the second. Unfortunately now (a year later) it has caused a lot of problems.

Mainly "that side" of the family thinks I'm nuts, like I broke the 11th Commandment or something.

What do YOU think? Was I right to be there for my daughter? That was my main concern.

My side of the family doesn't see anything wrong with that. I was always taught to be a good father in every possible way I could.

Update:

FROM ORIGINAL MESSAGE POSTER:

Thank you everyone for your kind words! Just when I was about to give up, on kind and understanding people in this cold world!!!

It's funny how you think this stuff out, but when it comes to the moment of writing it, something always gets left out!

I have to add, that I was wanted in the delivery room. In fact we talked about it early on. Later my daughter told me "I wanted to hold your hand. But..." Later she said she was scared because her mother was there (my ex) and we don't get along. I was there for my daughter. It was her day, not mine, or my ex's! My ex had seen every one of "her" kids born, and all the grandkids. I was always busy working, trying to keep the bills paid and clothes on the kids, etc., so I always seemed to miss the important moments. Here, you just about to have a heart attack before they let you go home. Jobs are nearly impossible to get anymore, so...

My daughter is not married, so there was no problem there.

Update 2:

I have read over every single answer carefully. I thank each of you that replied. Almost every answer was positive. (Actually they all were, based on my imperfect information as I wrote it). I wish I could now vote each one of you as "best answer" because each answer was clearly from the heart. I don't think its fair to award only one answer as "best." There should be a Miss America-type thing, where there's runner's up and such.

The one I chose? I chose because it was simple, to the point, and very human.

Again, thank you everyone for your wonderful input!

21 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Sounds as though there are SOME that need to Mind-Their-Own-Business....if your daughter wanted you there and you wanted and needed to be there...then WHO exactly was it hurting...it sounds as though you have a close..warm and loving relationship with your daughter and that is ALL that counts...No Worries!

  • 1 decade ago

    It's only crazy if you invited yourself into the delivery room without the mother or father asking you to be there. A baby's delivery is a personal time for the parents, they are entitled to choose whoever they want to be in there. If they didn't ask you to be there, you have no right to position yourself there like you deserve it. You didn't mention if your daughter is married or has a partner that was also there. You are right that you should be a good father in every way possible, but the boundaries change once your daughter is an adult and has her own partner...you aren't the main man in her life anymore, so her husband and her have the right to decide what level of involvement other family members have for these type of things.

  • 1 decade ago

    If your daughter had no problem with you being there and it wasn't a perverted thing, and you were truly in your heart there to support your daughter then forget what other people think and enjoy your grandchild. Everyone has an opinion and you since to have been where you needed to be.

    My dad almost ended up having tobe there formy first child birth because my husband was coming in from sea duty. I would have appreciated it greatly because childbirth is not something one should have to do alone and if I had to have anyone I would hope it would be my parent. Those who are judging you must be perverted. Forget them and continue to love on your daughter and your grandchild and know that you shared in a special moment for your daughter and your grandchild.

    I commend you Know that I am a nurse and my goal is midwifery.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    So tell her that. the main considered necessary element is which you're feeling as comfortable as achieveable (somewhat conversing, decrease than the circumstances). it incredibly is unquestionably an intimate 2nd, to assert the least, with your genitals splayed out and on exhibit for the international to work out. i do no longer see the could have a crowd in there at that distinctive 2nd, and in case you sense an identical way, you're able to make your thoughts commonplace. i'm surprised on the style of mothers and mothers in-regulation presently who seem to sense like they're entitled to be in the transport room. I doubt a single one in all them had the different kinfolk contemporary whilst they gave delivery.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    As long as the person delivering the baby was ok with it..then I say that's great!! Personally, I would not want any male relative of mine in the delivery room!LOL...Only my ex-hubby (hubby at the time) was in the delivery room with me when I had my daughter!If your daughter was okay with it then who cares what everyone else thinks? Don't worry about them!!! you were being a supportive grandfather!! Good for you!!! Kudos!!

  • 1 decade ago

    My dad was there for my dd1's birth...and there was no curtain, so he saw everything, lol. He also wasn't able to come to my sister's son's birth, so it was really important to him.

    He helped me through my conctractions when my hubby was getting the car ready...if my dad wasn't their I would have been left alone and I DID NOT want that...

    My dad can't make it to my dd2's birth but my sister willl be there this time...she's a massage therapist so I'll definitely be putting her to work, lol.

    Also since my parents can't be there and my mom has never been to any of her grandchildren's births, we plan to video tape and take pictures...tasteful of course, nothing graphic...don't want to scare any kids that will be watching, lol.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    It is entirely up to the person having the baby! Me, I ONLY wanted my husband in the delivery room. I have friends that have had their moms, sisters, dads, friends, etc. there for the birth.

  • 1 decade ago

    as long as it was your daughter's decision! i invited my father and he respectfully stayed by my head while i pushed. Held my head up and all so he was able to be a part of the delivery. i do believe that is being a good father to your daughter.

  • 1 decade ago

    Who is and isn't in the delivery room is a personal choice of the woman giving birth. No one else has a say. If she feels comfortable with you being there, fine. If she says no, you need to respect her decision.

  • 1 decade ago

    I wouldnt have mine or my partners dad in there no way! but every family is different. But no way if theres no curtain or anything to stop you seeing, thats just wrong! So no I think its not right, but if the girl doesnt mind????

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.