Do you go through the American Idol questions and give thumbs down to every person who says...?

I only give thumbs down if they bad-mouth my guy - David Cook. I don't think David A is all that great though.

Definitely not. I give a thumbs down to the people who put other people down.

I am a huge David Cook fan, but if someone said that they loved David Archuleta and wanted him to win, I would give them a thumbs up because they didn't say anything negative about anyone else.

Well, I'm an Archie fan so I will not do that.

Some D. Cook's fan do it though.

RELAX PEOPLE, I said SOME.

But seriously, Archie and Cook's fans don't seem to see eye to eye.

I don't hate David Cook. I actually love how he sang Hello.

But I put thumbs down to any comments that belittle Archie.

I mean you can post comments and all but I think you need to be a bit discreet.

No, I don't do that. I mean there's nothing wrong with liking Archuleta... :|

nope! thats a stupid reason to give someone a thumbs down! i give thoose ppl thumbs up!