Does anybody think Syesha should have gone home?

No, I think it was Brooke's time. She hasn't done very well the past couple of weeks, but Syesha has done great. Syesha deserves to stay on a little longer because she is a good singer...I think Brooke needs a little more vocal training. Don't get me wrong, I think Brooke is great and she is going to be a star...she just needs a tiny bit of help, and some confidence. Syesha may be forgettable, but she is a strong singer and performer.

Syesha is WAY better than Brooke. Brooke was pretty bad this week, but Syesha has had better weeks...

Brooke was worse than Syesha, but Syesha will go next week

NO! Brooke deserved to go home

♥ Jason Castro ♥

Nope, Brooke was a Carole King wannabe.

It was time for no more tears! Although, yes Syesha's nothing special. blah

Trailor trash like you is why Syesha is doing so poor. She is very talented and most people are like....already had Jordin Sparks win..so don't need another type like that winning.. Or people are plain out being racist. Brooke on the otherhand forgets her stuff way too much..

she just wants to be famous. she was on some other reality show a couple years ago. but it was def brookes time.

No, Jason should have gone home tonight. Syesha won't win but Brooke would not have won either.

I Think dreads should go home! I Mean he's good but now American Idol Is turning into a popularities contest.

no way! shes wayy better then Brooke, and a better performer.