Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Mathematics question...?

Where and how can I learn about how to understand and write mathematical proofs?

It isn't very well covered in my current coursework at the college. Am I going to be forced to get a masters before they teach me this? I would rather start learning it now...?

Any help will be greatly appreaciated.

Thanks

5 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    This doesn't happen in your first couple years at undergrad. Normally in your late second year or early third years you start to take proof based classes.

    If you are interested now, I know of a book that made me fall in love with the subject and want to be a 'pure' mathematician.

    The book I would recommend is:

    Set Theory and Metric Spaces

    By Irving Kaplansky ISBN: 0821826948

    As I said this book made me fall in love with the subject of mathematics and want to do that as opposed to something else. I took this in the beginning of my 3rd year of undergrad.

    It really isn't too hard to read, however it is kind of hard to start writing proofs on your own without someone to guide you. You may go around and ask some teachers if they have an introductory course for advanced mathematics, like I took, ask if you just can sit in or ask to take it pass/fail.

    Or perhaps you can find someone that is willing to take you under their wing and personally guide you in becoming a mathematician.

    Set theory is good to learn how to read and write proofs and it is enlightening as to how useful and powerful the subject is. It makes a good solid introduction to the things that will follow. However it is only the beginning.

    There are 4 main areas of pure mathematics that you should be familiar with. If you intend on going to graduate school and getting a PhD then you must choose one of them to master in. (Actually you choose a sub-category of a couple in some crazy intersection of these different theories.)

    The 4 areas are:

    Abstract Algebra

    Real Analysis

    Topology

    Complex Analysis

    Some good first year books that I had are:

    Abstract Algebra, An Introduction

    2nd edition

    Thomas Hungerford

    ISBN: 0-03-010559

    Principles of Mathematical Analysis

    3rd edition

    Walter Rudin

    ISBN: 0-07-085613-3

    Topology

    James R. Munkres

    ISBN: 0131816292

    Complex Variables and Applications

    James Ward Brown & Ruel V. Churchill

    ISBN: 0072872527

    Any of these, I feel, provides a good, well written introduction to the subject and shows you how to write proofs and gives you a good understanding of the layout of the subject and a taste of things to come. See if your library has them, perhaps you could do some reading on some stuff on the internet, and get a feel. In the end you really do need some book so that you can see the whole layout and not just the snippets and 'important parts'.

    Personally I'm fond of Algebra. I like how accessible the topic is and the types of questions one asks and answers with the subject. Depending on what you find interesting will guide you to really like one topic and get to like it.

    Good luck and feel free to ask me any questions you might have!

  • 1 decade ago

    Writing mathematical proofs is quite simple. Most books aren't about writing proofs since there isn't one perfect process to writing a proof.

    However, I would give you the following steps:

    1. Think about the entire process through which something is going to be proved.

    2. If you are going to prove things are every step... say f1,f2,..fm, then make sure that you can prove these by any means necessary.

    3. Please make sure that a uniform method is used i.e. if possible use similar approaches for proving f1..fm.

    4. Using the series of conclusions, c1..cm, prove the final result.

    This is not the best way to probably write proofs since I believe that most proofs come from sheer creativity. You need not take a Masters for that.

    Here is a link to understand the standard method of writing mathematical proofs:

    http://zimmer.csufresno.edu/~larryc/proofs/proofs....

    Most of the time though, you need to believe in what you want to prove and just look for the means to prove it.

    Hope this helps.

  • 1 decade ago

    A mathematical proof is a set of steps based in mathematical fact that use deductive logic.

    This will not help you :)

    I will look up some sites that might help.

    It would help to know what topic you are studying. Geometric proofs are often different then algebraic proofs.

    Geometric proofs

    http://www.sparknotes.com/math/geometry3/geometric...

    http://www.themathlab.com/geometry/mathcourt/write...

    In the mathlab site click on the examples

    The difference between a two column proof and a paragraph proof is just how you write it. The concept is the same. How do you know this _______ is true?

    http://pass.maths.org.uk/issue7/features/proof1/in...

    It also may help to post examples of questions here to answers to get the idea of how to prove things by seeing others do it.

    I was very confused about proofs when I started my degree in mathematics. It is a concept you have to grasp. Seeing alot of examples may get you to start to understand how people are making connections.

  • Andy
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    So you're studying maths at college degree level? If you feel you're not learning enough about proof, or rigour? There's no easy way to learn it, it should be covered in pretty much all the courses you'd study at that level. And in a way, if you're not learning it now, then what kinda stuff are you studying?

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    what mathematical statements do u actually want to prove? or do you mean u want to learn about proving methods like, by induction, inspection etc..

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.