Am I the only one who loved Fantasia's performance on American Idol last night?

No I liked it too. I thought it brought a lot of life to an otherwise boring show. I suppose those people want everyone to look like the girl next door and to sing ballads or patriotic songs. They are assuming Simon`s facial expression showed disgust, maybe he`s thinking Wow!!!

No really it was STUPID. It was WAY over the TOP. HER fans don't want to see something out of Broadway. I didn't understand a thing she was singing about. Did you see Simon's expression? Well, I had the same expression. I had to turn the volume down. If that's any indication about what her next album is going to be like then I won't be buying it! Okay I didn't buy the first one! LOL I did like her on the show. She did a great job. I'm team Chris Daughtry, Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson! Lovin' the two David's!

Yeah, I didn't think it was that bad at all. There have been much worse sung on that show and I thought the back up singers and Fantasia did a nice job working together and it was a fun song. I think it was really the outfit and the hair that caused more of the reaction. That was a little over the top, and she could've come up with something better. If she has a stylist, they should be fired.

I think Simon's face matched the faces of the majority watching by TV.

sorry sweetie, but i think you're on ur own this time =D

dont get me wrong, the girl can sing her firey red hair off... but THAT particular performance was horrible. i dont know what she was thinking doing all that screaming like a kid having a tantrum. simon's face says it all: PLEASE... STOP... THE MADNESS!!

better luck next time fantasia =)

actually i dont think it was nearly as bad as ppl are making it out to be. i was never a fan of hers but i actually liked it, it was like a party or something! but it didnt really show off her vocal ability.

I didn't think it was so bad, kind of fun and different. Her clothes weren't so bad either, glad she didn't wear a dress.

I think you are the only one.. lol. Did you see Simon's face?!?! That was just priceless!

I didn't like it it sounded like she was yelling instead of singing and she has such a beautiful voice.

it was too dramatic for me, too loud.. and she was like screaming i dunno.. see simon's utterly appalled face? haha. no deny its upbeat and hot. but just a little over though i don hate