Is Archuletta really what American Idol is all about?

if you think irritating teenagers then yes, if you think pure undiscovered natural raw talent - NO

COOK TO WIN

Yes I do. American Idol is suppose to be a pop star who wins for a record deal, as the prize. Since the beginning of time pop has always sold because of attraction and always will. Britney has a cute voice but it is not as cute as the outfits she strutted on stage. Same thing goes for N Sync. They were cute to the girls but was their music really worthy of a record deal? It was bubble gum pop that only lasted a minute. It was the same thing with the Beatles. Yes they are legendary and their writing skills were out of this world; their lyricism is genius but it was the fact that they were hot to the young girls that sold. So if you think that because he is young or because he is so sugar sweet and cut that he is annoying and that that makes him inappropriate for the winner, you are wrong. The whole package goes into this and he has it.

Yep, how many times a young girl can push redial on a telephone! That's why he is gonna win, even though it should be David Cook. The teenage girls do not care about talent, all they care about is someone who is "cute".

Its not about talent like it should be. I think that if David Cook doesn't win, he will probably still outsell David A. on the first CD they put out and he will be around a lot longer too.

No. "American Idol" is about finding the next, well, american idol.

Id like an order of david archuleta hold the archuleta EXTRA COOKIE!!

Yes I think its about someone who is a great singer, not just an entertainer.

No he's not he's trying to be what Simon says" A chuwa wa trying to be a tiger"

yes he is the complete package! can sing....play the piano and appeals to all age groups!

I guess! He is perfect! He is what it is all about!

YES!!!!!!!!!!!! Archuleta will win and he deserves it!!!!!!!!!