Do you think the All Star Final Vote has been great for baseball?

Yes, it is good if you put in that perspective.

I live in Tampa, and it the exact same as in St. Petersburg.

However, the voting is bad for baseball.

If the ASG has weight to it (homefield advantage in the WS), it should not be the fans that are voting, it should be the managers of teams. Otherwise, it is just a popularity contest. Like Jason Varitek, he should not have gotten into the ASG.

Yea, i think it has, because it takes all the talented baseball players and put them on a team that will do really good. Also it will give the players from all over the country a chance to get to know other players and that is good for their self esteem.

Giambi and Wright will most likely win because they both play in a large city, so there are more votes to be had in NYC then in Tampa Bay.

I guess. But I think fans should get to vote for one player, fan voted all-star. Then players vote for the rest of the team.

I think it has & all home teams who have players chasing that last spot on the all star team, they will vote for their hometown player, which is okay & I did cast my vote, but not all for any one player in particular

Vote Hart and Longoria. And personally, I don't care.

yes

i'm a huge eva fan! i love the rays because i live in seminole, which is near! i hope he goes, if he doesn't i will be pissed because i voted 212 times!

heck ya evan evan evan evan!!!! lol anyways yes because maybe they can use some of the money they get to get instant replays...

I think it always makes the Ballot more interesting

very final 4 Babe Ruth >> >>>>Babe Ruth( even nonetheless i like the pink sox) Ted Williams >> Mickey Mantle >> >>>> Willie Mays Willie Mays>> Lol some physique voted for bonds over Ruth in the 1st around wow what a nongenius LMFAO