Who are the top 10 NL players of all time?

I’ll do it as a team, just for fun.

Johnny Bench

Albert Pujols (so far)

Joe Morgan

Honus Wagner

Mike Schmidt

Stan Musial

Willie Mays

Henry Aaron

Greg Maddux RHP

Steve Carlton LHP

Randy Johnson was great, but his career is too split AL/NL to make either of my lists.

Hank Aaron

Willie Mays

Stan Musial

Honus Wagner

Rogers Hornsby

Mel Ott

Sandy Koufax

Mike Schmidt

Barry Bonds

Christy Mathewson

Apologies to Roberto Clemente, Ernie Banks, Pete Rose, Pete Alexander, Johnny Bench, Warren Spahn, Greg Maddux, Steve Carlton, Tony Gwynn, Eddie Mathews, Dave Winfield, Bob Gibson

I would say:

Hank Aaron

Willie Mays

Stan Musial

Roberto Clemente

Sammy Sosa

Barry Bonds

Ozzie Smith

Mike Schmidt

Johnny Bench

Greg Maddux

1. Musial

2. Aaron

3. Griffey Jr. in prime when hurt beginning of reds career

4. Greg Maddux

5. Bob Gibson

6. Sandy Koufax

7. Mike Schmidt

8. Nolan Ryan

9. Christy Mathewson

10. Bonds (last cuz of roids)

1.Hank Aaron

2.Willie Mays

3.Mike Schmidt

4.Stan Musial

5.Pete Rose

6.Randy Johnson

7.Greg Maddux

8.Steve Carlton

9.Tom Seaver

10.Albert Pujols

I'm going to assume you mean position players:

Hank Aaron OF

Willie Mays OF

Stan Musial OF

Clemente OF

Johnny Bench C

Willie McCovey 1B

Ryne Sandburg 2B

Mike Schmidt 3B

Ozzie Smith SS

Pete Rose -- where ever

Start with Mays, Aaron, Bonds and Musial. The rest may get more arguments. In my lifetime I think of McCovey, Bench, and Morgan.

Ack, I forgot pitchers. To Bob's list add Kofax and Gibson.

1) Mays

2) Aaron

3) Bonds

4) Schmidt

5) Frank Robinson

6) Clemente

7) Musial

8) Joe Morgan

9) Ott

10) Seaver

**in no particular order**

10)