Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is there any way to convince the "LHC will kill us all" folks it won't happen?
I've been watching the intense barrage of "Will the LHC end the world?" questions and it started me wondering -- what is the best way to address folks who hear this and start to panic?
I blame the media for fueling this issue. They love to go with an outrageous story that will get attention no matter how absurdly improbable it really is. Still, when they get people worried about things I understand completely why these folks want to know more.
How can we make any progress?
9 Answers
- suittiLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
In addition to the media fueling this, there are people who are actively anti-science. These people search the scientific literature for interesting stuff. It's best if they can quote an actual scientist. So a scientist speculates on what one might get at high energy. They ask other scientists in public forums about it. People do the math and notice that 1) it's harmless, and 2) cosmic rays have been doing it for eons, so it's safe. But there's still the question which is quotable and attributable, even if it's obsolete. So armed with a quote, they feed it to the media, which never checks to see that it's obsolete, or even sends a note to the quoted scientist to check. Out the story goes.
Here on Y!A, you get not just adults who have some clue that all this happens, but 13 year olds who haven't had time to have much science background. It's largely these that are posting the questions. We could get pissed off that we're answering the same question over and over, or we could generate reasonable replies, put it in a file for repeated posting, and be polite. This is an outreach opportunity. So do outreach. Was there some other progress you thought you might accomplish? It's not like we're going to do Nobel Prize work here.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Put all your appointments with them on thursday. ;)
No honestly, I think you have to differ between two kinds of people here:
Trolls - don't look if the question they want to ask has been answered before, don't actually want a answer, but they just want to see their stuff in the WWW. Vain like hell.
Smart people: Ask different questions, don' repeat stuff and are really interested into learning new stuff.
It is the trolls, which makes this site a bit annoying currently. Lets throw them into a Black hole.
- meanolmawLv 71 decade ago
nope... it's not just the media... it's a few dipwads who like to feel important and 'big' by posting dumbass questions about it with "OH, I"M so SCARED" attached.... while the really scared kids sit there and read and believe it all..... how I wish I had a 'delete this crappiola' button!!....
we just have to keep repeating the same stuff... it's NOT going to make a black hole that will eat the world.... you still have to pay the rent this month.... and no, you're not going to die.... hopefully those who need to know the truth will go look for real info and realize that the idots who are pushing this stuff are dorks.............
- 1 decade ago
Even if the LHC created a black hole, the black hole would be too small to cause any damage. It would just pass through the earth and nobody would notice, and even if it did grow in size, it would take billions and billions of years to become enough to pose a threat to the Earth.
- 1 decade ago
No.... they're usually the same people who take the "we never landed on the moon' arguments seriously. They'd rather be suspicious and not believe than research & find out.
And, like the man said... "You cain't fix stupid."
Yes. I said, "Cain't."
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Yea. Tell them to chill until Thursday. Then they will wake up and realize that we are all still here.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
If these people would actually look it up and read about it they would not be worried. Here is a link.