Is this a fair trade? Addai & Dallas Clark for Forte & Witten?

Lets just look at this from Fantasy Points point-of-view. These are Yahoo! Sports standard scoring also.

Addai = 48.2 and Clark = 13.6

TOTAL = 61.8

Forte = 79.5 and Witten = 56.2

TOTAL = 135.7

** Note: I love what you wrote about being a 'savvy manager' and your right about selling high and buying low. But I don't see Addai-Clark putting up #'s to catch Forte-Witten.

You ask is this trade fair... numbers don't lie!

I agree with George K. The point of trading is misinterpreted quite often. So you are selling on the name (Addai) who has done nothing for Forte (Mr. Consistancy) and the stud Witten? I think you know who is getting the better deal don't you?

Well first of all trading is not for "getting the better deal". That's not the point. Saying that this trade is only for trying to sucker someone else in for a high name guy. So I'm sure your the one getting Forte and Witten. Am I right?

sounds to me like a trade just to make a trade. you're losing a little at rb and gaining a little at te. even swap. only do it if you like the other two guys better. one benefit tho is if indy has a bad game you don't lose out on 2 guys.

witten and forte are way better than clark and addai witten runs hard i mean really hard clark is good but not as good a witten both forte and addai are good but witten is better than clark so go for it