Who would win, Lesnar or Emelianenko?

Fedor would beat Lesnar at this point in Lesnar's MMA career. He doesn't have enough experience, and to beat Fedor, Brock needs good submission knowledge and defensive skills.

We will see how far those skills have progressed if Lesnar is matched up with Nogueira after the Big Nog vs. Mir fight. If Brock can pull off a victory over Big Nog (I'm a Lesnar fan, but would actually pick Nogueira to beat Brock right now), then it might be safe to say that Brock would be a good opponent for Fedor, especially if Brock finishes Nogueira; something Fedor couldn't do (nor could anybody else). But once Brock does have good enough submission knowledge and defensive skills, he will have a definite chance at beating Fedor if they were to fight.

So as of right now, or within the next year or so, I would say that Fedor would win, as he, Big Nog, and probably Josh Barnett are the only 3 guys I would give definite advantages to over Lesnar even now in his career. But after at least a year from now, I would definitely give Brock a good chance, and probably pick him to get the upset win over Fedor.

Honestly at this point in his career Lesnar has no chance. Hes just to inexperienced. Give him a few more years then we will see...

P.S. Randy would get absoulutely destroyed by Fedor

Edit - But if you look at it like that Randy beat Sylvia in a decision whereas Fedor beat beat him in around 30 seconds? Once Brock has more experience I think he has a better chance to beat Fedor than any other heavyweight right now, but he better watch his back cause Cain Valasquez and Shane Carwin are coming.

dont be such a homer.

Lesnar caught Randy and Randy was winning that round before he got caught, Emelianenko has a MUCH stronger chin than Randy which he's proven consistently, Fedor was slammed onto the top of his head by Kevin Randleman and wasn't even dazed by it, Randy is a stud but Fedor would beat him, and Fedor would beat Lesnar without a problem he's fought guys bigger than him and won without issue and he's got an iron jaw and I've never seen him dazed or wobbled by a blow and I've seen nearly every fight of his he wasn't even fazed by Crop Cop's head kicks, he's a better fighter than Lesnar any day of the week.

On sheer skills, Fedor. This is one of those fights where, for Brock to win at this stage of his career, he needs to rock Fedor with a huge shot early and then finish him. The longer that fights drags on, Fedor's superior fighting skills come into play. The only way it can end if it drags on is with Fedor submitting Brock.

We all know that Fedor emelianenko would win easy. It is so obvious !

Definitely Emelianenko :)

they shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence. Fedor would humiliate him.

edit @ragtown

although i agree with you, Fedor has been hurt with punches, both Fujita and Cro Cop had him doing the tippy toe dance, but that just shows he's got great recovery

Fedor Emelianenko. simple. maximum people who in simple terms watch the UFC, have not any thought of ways tactically clever, Fedor is. while he develop into struggling with Hong guy Choi - a guy who develop into three times his length, he used the floor in the process the combat, reason he knows larger combatants are in risk of submission while on the floor. And while he develop into struggling with great Nog, he tried his superb in the process the combat, on his ft and not on the floor. reason he knows great Nog's an authority on BJJ. And if he develop into GnP'ing great Nog, it may be over for Fedor himself.

In short. I think Emelianenko would win hands down.

lesnar would give him the f5 and then a shooting star press and win