Would you do this trade?

My first instinct is you have peavy so you can afford to give up beckett and you have K-Rod so you can afford to get rid of Papelbon however Upton is good but he's not gonna change your team offensivly by himself and Martinez isn't going to do much as well, so I think you might as well keep your pitching staff as is and see how your team does and your a boston fan aren't you having Papelbon Beckett Dice K Masterson and Pedrio all too obvious and no Yankees lol

I'd keep the pitchers in this case. Both are absolute studs and pitch for a winner.

dang. i dont want to be a jerk or anything man but this team is horribly bad.

with your team id keep the pitchers. its true you need offensive help but i think your OF will pull out just fine. adam jones is primed for a breakout year. dont do the trade

its very hard to say, without knowing who is on your team

if you had 4 closers, i would rather victor and upton

if you already have an awesome catcher, i woudl rather have papelbon and beckett

it is very difficult saying what is what if we dont know who is on your team

if you need pitching, i like side A

if you need hitting , i like side B

do that trade you have great pitching