Fantasy baseball trade help- quick!?

I get:

Ramon Ramirez

Jermaine Dye

I give:

Sin-soo Choo

Matt Lindstrom

This is essentially Choo for Dye (but he doesn't know that) because Lindstrom is about to lose the closers job (and I have 5 closers anyways). Choo has actually been better than Dye as of late, and I like his average, (I have no spot for Ramirez on my team).

Do I take this deal? (I'm leaning towards a yes)

My team (roto 12-team 5X5)(yes I ended up with A-rod and Wright on the same team...I swindled another manager):

C

John Baker

(Fla - C)

C

Mike Napoli

(LAA - C)

1B

Prince Fielder

(Mil - 1B)

2B

Chone Figgins

(LAA - 2B,3B)

3B

David Wright

(NYM - 3B)

SS

Ben Zobrist

(TB - 2B,SS,OF)

CI

Álex Rodríguez

(NYY - 3B)

MI

Ryan Theriot

(ChC - SS)

OF

Jerry Hairston Jr.

(Cin - 2B,3B,SS,OF)

OF

Jason Bay

(Bos - OF)

OF

Denard Span

(Min - OF)

OF

Shin-Soo Choo

(Cle - OF)

OF

Álex Ríos

(Tor - OF)

Util

James Loney

(LAD - 1B)

P

Roy Halladay

(Tor - P)

P

Roy Oswalt

(Hou - P)

P

Zack Greinke

(KC - P)

P

Frank Francisco

(Tex - P)

P

Scott Downs

(Tor - P)

P

Kevin Gregg

(ChC - P)

P

LaTroy Hawkins

(Hou - P)

P

Rick Porcello

(Det - P)

P

Tommy Hanson

(Atl - P) NA

BN

Asdrubal Cabrera

(Cle - 2B,SS) DL

BN

Carlos Quentin

(CWS - OF) DL

BN

Stephen Drew

(Ari - SS)

BN

Milton Bradley

(ChC - OF)

DL

Conor Jackson

(Ari - 1B,OF) DL

BN

Matt Lindstrom

(Fla - P)

BN

Ubaldo Jiménez

(Col - P)