is hilary duff actually talented?

I think she's just pretty and people like to look at her. Look at the Maxim issue with her in it if you don't believe me. As for her singing, she was totally coached and has some major production work done in the studio for her to even be on key. And her acting, well there's a ton of actors out there who couldn't act their way out of a paper bag.

I enjoyed the two. Lindsay greater so via fact of advise females, I by no ability cared for Hilary's video clips. Hilary had an attractive voice & song or 2, I by no ability cared for Lindsay's song. they're the two particularly yet at their bests Lindsay's prettier.

Not really.

when I was like 8, I saw her in concert, and she sounded like she was a cat being hit by a lawnmower, and I know, that most people don't sound terrific live, but like this was rip your ears out horrible. And yeah, people need to not waste money on all her crappy concerts, like seriously, and yes, alot of people are sooooooooooo much more talented than her.

I think she's ok. I used to be a really huge fan of her but now it seems like she doesn't even do much of anything anymore. I mean she's not bad it's just that there's some other celebs that I like now that I think are more talented than she is now.

yeah ure right ,s he cant really cat , all the roles ive so far seen her doing are pretty much the same .

and right again ..there are great actors out there and ppl are wasting their money on her , its just the film industry isnt only abt gud acting anymore i guess.!

she can sing i suppose , but ive hrd only one of her songs , and she kept saying '' beat of my hrt'' over and over ..if all her other songs are like tht , then she fails us as an artist !

Wow, you don't hear anything about Hilary Duff anymore! I used to love the show Lizzie McGuire. :) There's only a few songs I like by her and they're mostly from movies she's in, like Raise Your Voice. Other than that, she's not be famous...well, she is..but not on Disney or whatever.

Well a lot of people grew up watching lizzie mcguire and listening to her music. i still love her and will always be a fan at heart.

well i did love her she was my teen idol when i was 11 but now i'm 16

yea she can't sing that good but u got to admit she is better then any of the piece of crap disney stars they have now

i mean...she was like the only star b4 who was a good girl and i liked that about her she didnt care what anyone thought...but know i dont know shes changing i mean i know shes growing and all but!!! whateve..... shes okaii i think shes really pretty though! :)

shes alright. no real talent in my opinion.