What do you think of the Cullen house in Twilight?

Question

Okay, now in Twilight isn't the Cullen's house supposed to be white, three stories, in a meadow were you can hear a stream? Isn't it also supposed to be HUGE, kind of boxy with an out-building that they renovated into a garage? Plus the window is on the wrong side of the house, it's supposed to be on the north side. Okay, what about the cars??? When Edward drives Bella to school aren't they supposed to be all in Rosalie's car, well there not they drive Rosalie and Emmett's car, and isn't the top supposed to be up on Rosalie's car. I noticed these flaws and they've been really eating at me, what do you guys think?

ALEX · Accepted Answer

Are you talking about the difference between the book and the movie?

Because obviously the movie isn't going to be exactly the same as the book. It's impossible. I admit that some things would be easier to make the same as others; like Rosalie and Emmett's cars but in the movie they don't appear as bothered by being conspicuous. 

And they're not going to build an entire house just for the movie.

bright lights · Answer

Another flaw that I've noticed is that Rosalie's car in the book is a BMW and in the movie it is a Mercedes. It bothers me but it would be hard to make a perfect replica of the way the Cullen house is described in the book and the movie is always a little bit or a lot different than the book.

Anonymous · Answer

Dude if movies were this exact they'd be boring. Films (as I'm assuming you're talking about film inconsistencies) are ADAPTATIONS.... not exact-visual-replicas.

Gosh.. book to film sticklers annoy me. I can understand being upset about major changes, but minor little insignificant details?

nikki · Answer

wow ok they didnt have all that much money to make twilight.therfore they couldnt put in every single little detail.movies dont do that anyway even if they do have a lot of money.

Trending News

What do you think of the Cullen house in Twilight?

4 Answers