Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

ebnic asked in HealthMental Health · 1 decade ago

Why is it that christians are not treated like say, schizophrenia patients?

Why is it ok to believe in god and not ok to have imaginary friends? god doesn't really do anything while imaginary friends actually talk to you so what up with that?

Update:

If you're offended by this question please don't answer it.

Update 2:

I know it sounds like a troll question and thats why I posted it here. I wanted to know why is it that the mind accepts the idea of god and rejects the idea of invisible friends. If there's some kind of motor response triggered by the fact that a lot of people are doing it?

Update 3:

I'm not talking about kid's imaginary friends. I'm talking about the mental illness in adults.

Update 4:

Whatever the disease is called.. I said Schizophrenia because I was reading a terrible story about this guy who had imaginary friends and what diagnosed with schizophrenia.

7 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Because in order to have a delusion it has to be a belief that can cot be accounted for by their culture. Religions are culturally based from region to region.

    Like the notion that people should wear cloths and not run around naked. Thats a pretty simplistic example but we don't diagnose someone has having a delusion because they feel they have to wear cloths because it is something that is normal for our culture.

    God and religion are normal to our culture. So it isn't abnormal for someone to believe in. Now if no one else in our society believed in God then that one random person who spoke of god and devil and haven would be considered delusional. But this of course would never happen because faith God religion are all normal things for our society and for cultures around the world

  • 1 decade ago

    Perhaps you should take this question over to the Religion section, where I am sure you can get reactions from all sorts. I presume that is what you are looking for. Personally, I would rather pass by this bait.

    Edit- Sorry, but given the number of adolescents on this forum, and the fact it did sound like a troll question, I gave you the standard answer. However, to answer your question. People with schizophrenia have problems with their perception of reality all the way around. It's not just a matter of having one imaginary friend. They just see the world entirely differently than you do, and the physical laws you accept do not apply for them. A religious person is still very well grounded in reality as you percieve it, and and for the most part is not expecting to see or hear God answer back in the same way another person would. The schizophrenic actually holds conversations with their imaginary friend, and believes they hear answers or actually see the person. It is possible to have the condition tied into religious beliefs though, and there have been times when people did consider some saints to be mentally ill. In fact, when a person claims to have visions, one of the first things people suspect is their sanity, and it is one thing they do check for. Fortunately there are not that many cases where the lines blur. I'm sorry I mistook you for a troll earlier, but in the future, if you have such a question it might help if you made the same statement you did this time- that you recognize it is a close call, but is not.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Schizophrenia is abnormalities in the perception or expression of reality. Quite a jump from mental disorder to kids having imaginary friends. Most religion hails a being no longer on this earth.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Schizophrenia is not "hav[ing] imaginary friends". Not even close. I have no use for Christians and I don't get offended by this question even though I am a paranoid schizophrenic. I pity you, not hate you.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    hi Steve i'm so sorry which you're having considered one of these perplexing time handling your ailment. you're saying which you have been discharged from the army by using psychological trauma which might propose that possibly something led to it. if it is the case, is it conceivable which you will get extra helpful while the muse reason is dealt with? All psychological ailment is perplexing to administration in spite of the undeniable fact that it extremely is controlled. i'm happy you're getting the psychiatric and scientific allow you to pick. in case you're born lower back contained in the spirit, and that i've got confidence you're, then you certainly're a toddler of God and you're saved. It would desire to at circumstances, be extremely no longer basic which you will parent what's authentic and what isn't. What you are able to desire to maintain reminding your self of is what you knew and what you felt once you first believed and carry directly to that. Jesus can't sentence you because of the fact you're mentally unwell. He is attentive to the on a regular basis warfare you have yet he's likewise attentive to your coronary heart and it is your coronary heart he's finding at. you will desire to love your human beings and relatives very plenty which you're so worried approximately their eternity. Jesus is attentive to your concerns and that i've got confidence the strategies that are so distressing to you will come earlier him as a prayer from the midsection, that they are going to be saved. even however in ordinary circumstances it may well be incorrect to no longer examine the bible, it might desire to be sensible to no longer examine it while your ailment is at it extremely is worst as i be attentive to you will bypass by using undesirable stages and stable. Many passages contained in the bible will play on your anxieties and could exaggerate them. attempt studying some verses that are comforting to you and communicate approximately those. The Lord is attentive to and loves you. he's on the ingredient of you and could no longer leave you. you're saved and could stay that way. If persons are intentionally exhibiting you verses that misery you, it extremely is because of the fact they do no longer seem to be understanding your ailment and the consequence it extremely is having on you. have confidence your psychiatrist because of the fact he's qualified that may additionally assist you and that i desire and pray that as you become grounded contained in the authentic international, you will additionally be attentive to that peace interior. God bless :)

  • ?
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    I see you gave this a lot of thought but I am stumped.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    lol yea post this in religion

    lmao ill be waiting to see wat kinda responses you get :)

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.