my brother is being falsely accused of sexually abuse?

Question

About 4 years ago my brother was accused of sexually abusing his daughter in the state of Montana. He was cleared of all charges. A year ago, he was charged again on the same charges. His ex-wife is the one who accused him of molesting his daughter because she was jealous of the close relationship he had with his daughter. She lost her parental rights last month and left the state. He would never hurt her. He has never hurt her. He is a single father who has devoted his life to his child. She was molested by a male babysitter. My brother has done two psycho-sexual evaluations and they have both proven him innocent, yet they are still going to put him through a trial. His attorney says he should just plead guilty. What should he do. He feels so hopeless yet I know he is innocent.

Update:

He is not being offered a deal. They just want to try him and put him away for 25 years. They have already taken my niece and put her in foster care. He has not seen her since November of 2008. Is there anyone out there that has been falsely accused and how did you prove your innocence?

Chellie♥ · Accepted Answer

why on earth would he plead guilty?!
the state will just take his daughter
he needs to get a better lawyer and fight the power!

Anonymous · Answer

Is his attorney telling him to plead guilty because he is being offered a deal? If not it is very poor counsel and you should definitely get a new lawyer. How old is the daughter? If she says he didn't abuse her and there is no other proof or witnesses to any abuse then no jury will ever convict him.

landress · Answer

i do no longer comprehend if that case had lots credibility. although MJ did no longer look too stable from it. It became glaring from forensics that he wasn't the squeaky sparkling 'Pied Piper' he'd provided himself as to the media, yet particularly a disturbed guy or woman with deep themes, who became applying little ones in a marginally self-indulgent way. He became abusing drugs and alcohol. He had little ones sound asleep interior the comparable room the place he had porn that became accessible to them, the babies have been attending to the booze, it infrequently seems an suitable, orderly or suitable environment for babies. They used this difficulty to objective and get him on different expenses which he'd offered his way out of on the time. And those expenses in all probability had greater substance than the 2005 case. yet he became being tried for the 2005 accusations and the jury had to pick upon that.

No More Abuse · Answer

I agree with the answer: get a better lawyer..if he is innocent than he stands his ground..and proves that this male babysitter is the molester and the guilty party..

Aleferny · Answer

psycho-sexual evaluations don't prove one's innocence or guilt to sexual abuse..... just how well they do on the evaluation!

If he's not guilty... then he shouldn't plead it.  He should hope the truth prevails..... because it usually does... but not always!!!!

Professor Chaos386 · Answer

Get a better lawyer.

SAM · Answer

if he was charged once and cleared of all charges he can not be charged again for the same crime

Trending News

my brother is being falsely accused of sexually abuse?

7 Answers