Did the Giants get ripped off in the Freddy Sanchez - Tim Alderson trade?

Yeah they got ripped off even if Freddy doesn't go on the DL Tim Alderson is going to be a #1 starter in a few years. I was very upset when the Giants made this trade, and now it looks even worse.

in the time he was playing he was hitting over .300 since he came. hes what they needed but they needed him healthy. and alderson wouldnt be a number one on most teams but a number two. the giants already have lincecum and cain and bumgardner waiting in the wings with solid 4 and 5 guys in zito and sanchez. if sanchez resigns and can stay for a few year s i dont think they got ripped off at all

Time will tell. They sure F'ed up tonight! I guess they really don't want to get into the post season. They ripped themselves off. Time for a managerial change!

The funny thing is people are saying the giants are saying its his shoulder but reality it is his knee that was bothering him before the trade. I still am mad about the trade.

if he leaves after this year it will have been a complete rip