Who should I start week 5 Eli or Garrard?

Start Eli. Even though he's injured, I think he'll still play and have a solid game...I have him too and plan on starting him.

Garrard, Eli may not even play and i've always thought that Eli is WAY overrated anyway.

Cardinals Kurt Warner (2 tds) Seahawks Matt Hasselback (2 td) Rams Marc Bulger (2 ints) 49ers J.T. O'Sullvine (a million td, 2 int) Patriots Tom Brady? (3 td) Dolphins Chad Pennington (a million td) charges Trent Edwarts (0 tds, a million int) Jets Brett Favre (3 tds) Panthers Jake Delhomme (a million tds, a million int) Buccaneers Jeff Garcia? (2 td) Falcons Matt Ryan (2 td, a million int) Saints Drew Bree (a million td) Colts Peyton Manning (2 tds, 2 ints) Texans Matt Sacab (0 tds 2 ints) Titans Vince youthful (a million td a million ints) Jaguars David Garrard (2 tds) Broncos Jay Cutler (a million td, 2 int) Chargers Phillip Rivers (2 tds) Raiders JaMarcus Russell (a million td) Chiefs Brodie Croyle? (a million td a million int) Giants Eli Manning (0 td) Cowboys Tony Romo (4 tds) Eagles Devonian McNabb (3 tds) Redskins Jason Campbell (a million tds a million int) Ravens Joe Flacco? (0 tds) Steelers Ben Rothlisberger (3 td) Bengals Carson Palmer (a million td) Browns Derek Anderson? (a million td, 3 int) Aaron Rodgers packers (a million td, 2 ints) Kyle Orton bears (a million td) Jon Kitna lions (3 tds) Tarvaris Jackson Vikings (0 tds)

although im a giants fan go with garrard they trust him too much and pass too much although he is good they need to run more but since they dont go with garrard

plus tommy is gonna yank eli asap

Garrard.

Jacobs is going to run all over Oakland.

i think you should start Eli.

He will probably start since the Gaints would want to see how he does.and they playing Oakland.