should i give this guy a chance?

I met a guy through a mutual friend and we've been talking/texting lately. i enjoy talking to him and we seem to have a little bit in common. he wants to go to dinner and hang out...i'm just not really sure how i feel about him. he's adorable but in a pinch his cheeks kind of way and i'm not really sure i'd have physical chemistry with him (he's a tiny bit femanine, it's hard to picture me with him as something other than friends). i'd rather have someone that makes me melt instead of makes me go 'aww'. i'm not completely deciding i don't like him at this point, should i give him a chance? i don't want to lead him on if i'm unsure of how i feel.