Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Ian E
Lv 6

Can anyone suggest some successful use of 'Irony' in music composed for cinema?

Inspired, stimulated, and excited by a recent question by Alberich, I timidly ask this, eager to discover something I have not yet encountered. As a minor contributor to cinema, 'irony', as a potent device, has usually fascinated me.

The 'Harry Lime Theme' ("The Third Man", about 1951?) is some of the most effective musical contribution I have ever encountered. It is a pleasant, easy-going ditty, played on a zither (of all things!), that subtly lets viewers know that the fearsome villain in in the vicinity.

[ A 'boom, boom' musical contribution (such as Hollywood would probably use today) would be laughable, surely?]

This, to me, is a model of the use of ironic music, music inserted to achieve the direct opposite of its apparent mood.

I call music that reflects what happens on screen 'melodrama', but not in a 'critical' way. 'Irony' is usually music used to shock because of its incongruity.

I was delighted to discover that Alberich was something of a film lover, and hope that there are others.

Music, beginning as noise added to the screening of a film to cover the noise made by the projector, has developed into a major ingredient of fine cinema.

Good cinematic music, however, is rarely noticed when viewing. When you do notice it, it is often inappropriate, often overdone, and rarely helpful to the whole. The cine composer learns to leave his/her ego at home quite quickly.

(Being an crusty, opinionated old man, I have to say that I would rather call a symphony a 'song' than call a film a 'movie'. Feel free, however, to call it what you will. In my country, Australia, cinematic productions are usually called 'pictures' [pronounced 'pitchas' quite often] or 'films' [pronounced 'fillums' in many cases]. That being so, perhaps 'movies' isn't so bad, after all?)

Update:

'an' crusty.... Sorry. 'a' crusty...

2 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I've seen quite a few films where the music is an upbeat orchestral piece (like a waltz), or a song about sharing love and happiness - or something similarly inane - while a vicious fight is taking place and someone is brutally murdered.

    I believe in those instances the director is attempting is to make the scene visually appear more evil by contrasting it with something happy.

    -----

    By the way, I'm from Australia too haha.

    Source(s): Good example from recently - the Watchmen film. I believe it's the scene where the Comedian is being killed at the beginning of the movie.
  • I have no clue Ian, but I am just passing through cos I love reading pretty much anything you write! I do hope you find the answers you are looking for though ... you contribute so very much to so very many.

    And by the way ... do you have any idea how very very much I would love to go to the movies with you?? We could see Twilight together! Or maybe we could attend an orchestral performance and listen to some songs?! If we discovered something we loved we could pop online and see if we could download it for free! Then we'd have it on hand to listen to some background music anytime we liked, whenever we were busily occupied doing ... well, whatever really!

    In the meantime, thanks for yet another fascinating post and I sincerely do hope you find the answers you seek ;-)

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.