Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

I don't think I love my boyfriend anymore. Did I do the right thing by breaking up with him?

My boyfriend and I have been together since 2008, it would be 2 years this February (if it matters at all, I am 21 and he is 28). For the past 6 months, I have felt like I am falling out of love with him. I do not get excited about doing things with him like I used to. He is just perfect though, sweet and caring and never mean to me. He is in a band and has given up going on tour just because he couldn't bare to spend that time away from me. Just a few weeks ago he even left flowers on my car! I just do not love him anymore, it's how my heart feels and I can not help it. I have stayed with him for this long because I am afraid to break his heart. Sometimes, I even think about other guys which makes me feel so guilty. (I have never and would never cheat on him.) The hardest part about this is that I have told him exactly how I feel, but he claims he is still so in love with me and I am the best thing in his life. I do not understand how we can feel such different ways about the same relationship. I finally broke up with him yesterday and already I am feeling regret. When I think of the long run, I am sure we will both get over it eventually and be happier out of this miserable relationship. But when I think of him as a person, I miss him so much and can not imagine never seeing him again (being friends is out of the question as he already said it would be too hard for him). I still care about him so much, and I honestly think he deserves to find someone who loves him deeply, rather than staying with someone like me, who is constantly bitter and depressed and unloving. Did I do the right thing to break up with him? Please share your stories or input, thanks.

Update:

Thank you so much everyone, this is really helping me.

For those of you who are saying girls prefer a*sholes, you are very wrong. My boyfriend and I almost never fought, and I did not take it as "oh, he's just being nice and hates fighting," I took it as he did not care enough to work things out. He would tell me I was right when I knew I was wrong. I felt like he just wanted a "girlfriend" as opposed to wanting "me." I am not trying to look like the victim, but I am not a bad person and I truly appreciated all the nice things he did, which is why I think he deserves to be with someone better than me.

21 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Oh honey I have the same issue. I know exactly how you feel. You regret breaking up with him but the only reason you do is because you hate the fact that he is hurt and it is all your fault. But it is not! You cannot help how you feel. You did the right thing. Don't sacrifice your happiness for someone elses. It will take time but he will get over it. If he loves you as much as he says he does he will settle for friendship.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    Aw hun it's always hard when a relationship ends. Some times you are so "blinded by love" that you don't notice when someone else might not be feeling the same anymore. I think that he might have seen that you were nearing the 2 year mark and started to get scared of the big commitment that is and how the fun of the honeymoon period has gone. He might of not been ready for such a huge commitment and thats why he was picking arguments. Or maybe he has seen someone else just start a relationship and the spark of there meeting has made him think your relationship is slightly flat? He could have just meet someone else? The possiblitys are endless but you have to accept his desision. How would it feel to be back together when something made him unhappy and not want to be in a relationship anymore? I don't think that you should call him, wait for him to call you. In the mean time i think you should have your cry day and then pick yourself up and show him what he is missing. Good luck babe and there is plenty more fish in the sea (even though it might not feel like that now)

  • 1 decade ago

    It's the right thing to do, because the way you respond to his sweet acts will eventually be bitter, if it wasn't already. Then he'll be hurt even more in the long run.

    I think most relationships end up like that at some point, and maybe it's just a loss of passion and not of love. Love is said to be passion, affection, and commitement. Passion is the most short-lived part. It's probably best not to judge whether or not you still love a person based on how much passion there is. (Not saying passion isn't important, just not the most important.)

  • Yes, you should have broke up with him. How nice and loving a person is does not determine if two people connect or are compatible.

    Like you said, he deserves to be loved in return the same way that he loves. You can't marry him just to spare his feelings. Both of you will be miserable in the end. If this is how you feel now, get out now before getting divorced later. It's best to be 100% sure you both share the same passion for each other, common interests, common goals, common personality, etc.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    Yes you did. While it is good that you feel that way for him and don't wish to hurt him there is a big rule in dating all should follow: "Love yourself first." If you are feeling like a relationship isn't working the way you want or just don't feel the spark anymore then don't. You only get 1 life and you shouldn't have to spend any of that time sitting in a situation that could be bad for you. Even if it's only just you who feels down about it fix it. You should always come first. As for him he'll get over it. If he doesn't and he descends to deppression or god forbid thoughts of suicide thats relationship abuse. He should never make you feel uncomfortable or upset because ofa break up. Just remember that you ALWAYS come first.

    Hope this helps :)

  • 1 decade ago

    No, you did not do the right thing. You feel regret and even said that you don't want him out of your life. Try this...

    Sit down with a piece of paper and a pen(cil) and I want you to list every little thing bad that he did, this includes all of his bad qualities. Then flip the piece of paper over and list every thing good that he did, which includes all of his good qualities. Now look at both sides of the paper which obviously has the most writing on it if it is the bad side then at least apologize and try to help him move on, introduce him to new people, or (as bad as this sounds) don't hang out with him as much. If it is the good side QUICK run and get him back!!!

    Hope this helps some!

  • 1 decade ago

    You did the right thing for him and for yourself, It is normal to feel empty and miss someone that you have gotten used to and that has been a big part of your life. Get involved with other things and give yourself (and him) time to adjust. Later on you may be able to have a friendship after you both have had some time.

    He has used all his charms to manipulate you into feeling guilty to stay with him and it would only have gotten worse.

  • 1 decade ago

    yes you did. Your only 21 and have some years of living to do before you settle down. he is 28 and ready to settle down. your just at 2 different points in your life. who knows what will happen a few years from now you may end up back together. but for now move on and live a little while you still can.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    YESSSSSSSSS! you did do the RIGHT thing!!! you are RIGHT! it sounds like a miserable relationship and staying for the sake of him as a person is not a goooooood reason...in the long run it would hurt him more.... i had the same prob....i loved a guy for a yr and then the last 6 months of the realtionship iw as like blah and in return was kinda mean to him...i felt like was missing out becasue i wasnt truely happy and i ended up doing things behind his back and hurting him more in the end...the longer youn wait.........the harder it is sooooo yeah you did tghe right thing and TIME will make it better! gooooooooood luck

  • 1 decade ago

    Nobody said doing the right thing was EASY...welcome to adult life.

    You did the right thing. I did the same thing when i was in college, and now I am married to someone who was worth the wait.

    Let it go, be happy for him, and let him be free to find that someone who will love him the way he loved you. She is out there, and he deserves her.

    Best of Luck.

    Dr.G

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.