Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Can a cop give you a ticket if he/she never sees the key in the ignition according to Arizona State Law?

I had a friend tell me that if you were to get pulled over, all that you would have to do is take out the key, even if you just set it on the seat next to you, and even if there is no one else in the car or anything the cop cannot give you a ticket because he/she did not see the key in the ignition. I want to know if this is actually true before I risk pissing off a cop if I ever get pulled over! And this doesn't apply to DUI's, I know, I'm talking about speeding tickets mostly.

Update:

I agree it sounds ridiculous, hence the skepticism, but there are also laws prohibiting donkeys sleeping in bathtubs in AZ. Our government is capable of obscene stupidity, so I thought it worth while to check it out.

11 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Well gee... Who was driving the car then? Those pesky alien space monkeys... They'll get ya every time.

    Seriously, what would removing the key even do? Would it just be an attempt to prove you drove the car without a key or what?

  • Kevy
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    That's like saying that once you stop the vehicle after it was speeding it is no longer speeding so you cannot cite him..... Makes no sense. A reasonable person will assume that the vehicle is operating on the street. Not to mention a seat belt violation in that state is a secondary offense, which means you have to be stopped for something along with seat belt anyway.

    I can see cross examination of the officer on the stand now. haha

    Officer, was the vehicle in operation when you observed the violation?

    Yes

    Was the defendant in the driver's seat?

    Yes

    Guilty

    Source(s): Police officer
  • Tim H
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    So I guess if you steal a car and hotwire it you will be all set.

    J, they got joke answers because this is a joke question (or at least it should be). Your answer is a joke too. Of course anything can be legal with the right lawyer. Once charges are brought then anything goes. I would love to see a public defender try and use your defense.

    Also, I am not a cop. Why would you assume we all are? If you have read any of my answers you would know that I am anything but a cop. Your foolish assumptions do harm to people like me who are actually trying to educate so that police reform can take place.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    even although my opinion isn't the main ordinarily shared i've got faith the guidelines in Arizona are not racist. the undertaking with unlawful extraterrestrial beings in Arizona is extremely severe. The kidnap fee and homicide fee have dramatically bigger. Now if others states have that individual same difficulty then they could desire to handle it. i'm no longer announcing immigrants are undesirable because of fact they're a huge area of our monetary equipment and that they do no longer take jobs from every physique because of fact no one might do the roles they do yet there are criminals and that they could desire to be apprehended and deported.

  • Jay
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Of course it isn't true. If the police catch you speeding, it doesn't matter if you take the key out of the ignition before he gets to your car. Your friend is either messing with you or is a moron.

  • 1 decade ago

    Oh my god! You found our one weakness, I had prayed for years that this would not go public! Now I will never be able to write another ticket ever again because the public knows all they have to do is take the key out of the ignition............................................................................

    Seriously, you should ask yourself if that even sounds like it might be true.

    EDIT:

    The pulling the keys out of the ignition and drinking advice is yet more bad advice on here. If you think that will keep you from getting a DWI then you shouldn't even drive sober. It is scary what people post on here and try to sell.

    Neither of these tactics will work.

    Source(s): "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing." (Edmund Burke)
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Good grief, the more I hang around the site the odder the questions get. . .

    Short answer is no, this is not true. You might get out of a ticket if you try this on an AZ officer, he may be too busy laughing to write the citation.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Your friend is a legal genius !!

    Of COURSE it`s true , Eunice ! Next time you get stopped for speeding ........... pull over ........... remove the key ............ light up a cigarette ......... sit back ...... blow smoke in the officer`s face ............ and remind him of the "no key in the ignition" law .

    Let us know what happens !

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Well in a law class we were told that is LEGAL in Connecticut, according to a law professor, even for DWIs... don't know much about the specifics... basically if you get the keys out AND THEN start drinking before the police reach your window, it prevents the investigation b/c they have no official proof of when you started drinking. So this only works b/c in Conn its legal to drink in your car as long as the keys aren't in the ignition. So oh well

    Only posted this because its sad to see five joke responses to a serious question... all from cops too theres a surprise...

  • 1 decade ago

    Don't trust your friend when they say, "Planting a bomb in the federal building, then setting it off from outside the building is NOT illegal."

    Source(s): *Facepalm*
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.