Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is there any community (civilised/uncivilised) on earth where homosexuality is seen as marriage material?
My question has to do about the claim that disapproval of homosexuality as something that was indoctrined by the Abrahamic faiths. While we can see practices of polyandry/polygyny and so on, can we ever find (can even be in any remote uncorrupted tribal community) a same sex union which is given the status of a socially accepted family unit.
Please note the usage "socially accepted family unit". I am not saying that relationships of curiosity or convenience or genuine interest were not openly prevalent - based on the position of the individual in society. This question has to do with social acceptance as a family unit bonded in marriage.
Please don't mention the absence of progeny as a cause. A childless couple are given the status of socially acceptable family unit.
9 Answers
- AndiGravityLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
Certainly. Many Native American societies accepted homosexual couples as a "socially acceptable family unit", provided the couple did all the work expected of a heterosexual couple. In fact, Native Americans tended to view homosexuality and gender identity as a part of the spiritual identity someone was blessed with, so they usually encouraged people to follow the path they felt best suited to.
If two males or two females fell in love, so be it. If a boy wanted to dress like a girl or live as a woman, that was his prerogative. To the Native American way of thinking, if such people were born then they were obviously meant to exist. So, the rest of the tribe usually didn't bother getting fussed about it, and got on with their lives.
Research the terms "two-spirit" and "berdache".
It's only since the arrival of the Europeans and the enforcement of the Judeo-Christian ideals upon Native American cultures that they began to develop homophobic attitudes.
So in answer to your question, yes. There have indeed been places in the world where homosexuality was considered fit for marriage.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
yeah rome, greece, Sodom, Gomorrah before they fell and the USA on it's way down
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Seattle is pretty darn close.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
No one said the Abrahamic faiths were the first or only one to indoctrinate homophobia. So even if every religion pushed homophobia it doesn't change the fact that most people in America are using the Bible to justify forcing people to abide by their doctrine.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Homosexuality wasn't really recognized as a sexual orientation until recently. Historically - there have always been homosexuals although they typically were not accepted in most societies.
Greece and Rome had some level of acceptance for homosexuality, although I'm not sure if it was recognized as a separate sexual orientation. It was also mixed with pederasty at times (and please don't get confused and think that homosexuality = pedophilia).
I'm under the impression that homosexuals have always existed, but for the most part lived their lives as a heterosexual and kept the rest behind closed doors.
Today, there are several countries that have socially accepted homosexuality, homosexual marriage, and homosexuals as parents. Those societies have not died off or suffered because of it.
Edit:
After seeing some of the above posts - please post links. I'm curious as well.
Source(s): agnostic atheist - CoreyLv 71 decade ago
Yes. And not just modern countries, and classical Rome (same sex marriages were legal until the after Christians took over). Various cultures throughout history have accepted same sex pairbonds. There were even homosexual unions, although seen through a different cultural light, in pre-columbian America. The term Two-Spirit, is used to describe them now.
- humynismLv 61 decade ago
Yes, I can't remember the name of the tribe, but it was an hour long special on National Geographic. I'll look for the show, and if I find it I'll return & edit my answer for you.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
nope. ur gay i assume?
- 1 decade ago
I don't know where they came up with my dad hating homosexuals. Up here in heaven, well, let me show you. *opens door to wedding with two men in pink suits*