Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Science & MathematicsMathematics · 1 decade ago

How to show this series converges?

Let a_n be the n_th positive integer whose decimal representation doesn't include the digit 9. Show that ∑(n = 1, ∞) 1/a_n converges. That is, the series

1 + 1/2...+ 1/8 + 1/10 + 1/11...+ 1/18 + 1/20....+1/28 + 1/30....

Thank you

4 Answers

Relevance
  • Ben
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    These problems where you leave terms out of the harmonic series based on the decimal representation are interesting, hard to grasp at first, but easy once you've seen it once.

    Let's group the terms by number of digits in the denominator. Considering the numbers as n-letter strings on an alphabet of 9 letters (0 to 8), the group of n-digit numbers without the digit 9 in them has no more than 9^n numbers. And each of them is less than 1/10^(n-1). So our sum is less than the sum over n of

    9^n / 10^(n-1)

    = 9* sum( (9/10)^n )

    which converges.

    Oh, one word about the grouping I did. Associativity doesn't always work with infinite series (just consider 1-1+1-1+... ). We can however use associativity when the terms are positive and monotonically decreasing as they are here.

    EDIT: Ah, thanks Jake. I was taking the latter sum to be from n=0, but didn't make that clear. Of course, just recognizing it as a geometric sum (with ratio <1) is enough here to claim convergence.

  • 4 years ago

    ? ? ((-a million)^(n+a million))*(a million/n) = -a million+a million-a million/2+a million/3-a million/4+a million/5-.... n=0 to teach a chain converges we could desire to nicely known the guy words convert to 0, which they do. yet that's not sufficient. ? ? ((-a million)^(n+a million))*(a million/n) = (-a million+a million)+(-a million/2+a million/3)+(-a million/4+a million/5)+ n=0 (-a million/6+a million/7).... =0 -a million/6 -a million/20 -a million/40 two -a million/seventy two-... Factoring the denominators: =0 -a million/(2*3) -a million/(4*5) -a million/(6*7)-a million/(8*9) Noting those components. The words have absolute values smaller than: ? ? (a million/n^2) = a million+a million/4+a million/9+a million/sixteen, which converges n=a million So our sequence could desire to converges. wish this helps. the final analysis is to teach that the sequence has words closer to 0 than a comprehend convergent sequence.

  • ohle
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    ? ? ((-a million)^(n+a million))*(a million/n) = -a million+a million-a million/2+a million/3-a million/4+a million/5-.... n=0 to tutor a series converges we could desire to appreciate the guy words convert to 0, which they do. yet that isn't sufficient. ? ? ((-a million)^(n+a million))*(a million/n) = (-a million+a million)+(-a million/2+a million/3)+(-a million/4+a million/5)+ n=0 (-a million/6+a million/7).... =0 -a million/6 -a million/20 -a million/40 two -a million/seventy two-... Factoring the denominators: =0 -a million/(2*3) -a million/(4*5) -a million/(6*7)-a million/(8*9) Noting those factors. The words have absolute values smaller than: ? ? (a million/n^2) = a million+a million/4+a million/9+a million/sixteen, which converges n=a million So our series could desire to converges. desire this helps. the secret's to tutor that the series has words nearer to 0 than a understand convergent series.

  • 1 decade ago

    One problem with Ben's solution:

    9^n / 10^(n-1)

    = 9* sum( (9/10)^n )

    SHOULD BE

    9^n / 10^(n-1)

    = 10* sum( (9/10)^n )

    However, the answer remains the same.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.