Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

cw21dlr asked in Family & RelationshipsFriends · 1 decade ago

Partnered female has male friend...opinions please?

I am a 57-year-old female who has been in a up-and-down relationship for 16 years. There have been some great times between us and some difficult times. There has been some cheating on his part (twice) and he has a great deal of insecurity.

My personal feeling is the cheater always feels cheated upon - because he/she does it, he/she feels anyone else is capable of it as well. He does not take into account a person's integrity or the monogomy the woman has maintained throughout. Despite the difficulties we have had, we remain caring and together.

I've as well been divorced for 17 years. About 4 years ago, I reconnected at a social event with a male friend, Rick - actually, my ex's (still) best friend and the best man at our wedding. I have known Rick for over 35 years. I have stayed in touch with Rick over the past few years and occasionally - maybe every 3 months or so - we've met for a couple of hours, at the most, of pool or a couple of drinks, just to catch up on news, who he's dating, small talk. This has occured both when my current relationship was on and, as well, during the times there were difficulties. The friendship with Rick has never been anything other than that -no flirting, nothing suggestive, definitely no intimacy of any kind whatsoever. I honestly feel this is just a good friend I have had for a very long time, someone I respect, but I 100% don't have any romantic feelings for him, and vice versa. On the occasions when I have hung out with him for a couple of hours, I have always given my boyfriend the head's up about what's going on. I have never in our 16 years together given him reason to doubt me; I've never lied to him about this friendship - I believe honesty is the best policy. And I firmly believe that after all these years of friendship with this guy if I were to have feelings for him I would have had them by now - and I don't.

He has an issue with me maintaining this friendship and I have an issue giving up a friend - and only a friend - that I have had longer than any other friendship I have had. I have absolutely no feelings towards this man and I have told my partner that. He argues that if I care about him and our relationship, I should give up this friendship; my feeling is that I am trust-worthy, always have been, and should not have to sacrifice the friendship because of his insecurity. To me, the issue is within himself.

He's asked me to put it to the Y/A community. Opinions, please.

Please don't suggest that we do something as a threesome - Rick was and still is my ex's best friend and that would just be too awkward.

2 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    No way....there is NO reason for you to give a friend that you have had that long. If you were going to have any type of feelings towards this man, it would of happened a long time ago. My husband has the same type of friendship with a female he has known WAY before he ever met me ( was his best friend from years ago). I completely trust him ( he has never given me a reason not to) and I would never ask him to give up a friend, especially a long time friend that has been there as long as she has. My thought is....if you have never given your partner a reason not to trust you......there should be no reason to worry. After all trust is pretty much 90% of what makes a relationship successful. He should trust you, and never want to have to put you in a situation where you are forced to between him and wonderful friend. If you were able to forgive him for his indiscretions then I think he should return the same respect and allow you to continue your friendship ( which it's not as if you two hang out daily). Now if you were wanting to hang out with guy friends all the time....then I would say he should have a right to put his foot down....but this isn't just some guy.....its a longtime FRIEND. Also, if there was going to be something a bit more than friends between you two, then I doubt you would tell your partner when your out with him....wouldn't you sneak around like all the others in the world having affairs?

  • isaac
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    I truthfully have no idea who's the "higher" of the 2. Both have benefits to being with you for the supply. What I do understand, with out hesitation is, EVERY guy must be there and spot the delivery of his baby. It is an revel in that's unsurpassed regardless of how generally he sees it. I concept my husband could puke, move out, whatever, however he was once thoroughly is awe and holds the ones 2 days as essentially the most super of his lifestyles.Twenty 2 years later, he nonetheless tells any expectant father he comes into touch with to enter the supply room.I could on no account wish to disclaim any guy that have.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.