Rate these Fantasy Baseball trades? (5 trades in 4 different leagues)?

Question

League #1:

I traded Derrek Lee CHC 1B for Chad Billingsley LAD SP.
(I have Tiexeira as my starting 1B and Cliff Lee is my ace pitcher.)

League #2:

I traded Robinson Cano 2B NYY for Justin Upton ARZ OF.
(I have Pedroia as my starting 2B; Start 4 OF and had Hamilton/Nyjer/Rajai/Hart/Beltran as OF depth before the deal.)

League #3:

I traded Justin Verlander DET SP for Mark Reynolds ARZ 1B/3B.
(Chris Davis is the only 3B eligible player on my roster pre-trade; SP depth includes Sabathia/Johnson/Peavy along with Verlander.)

League #4:

I traded Youkilis BOS 3B/M.Gonzalez BAL CL for ARod NYY 3B/N.McLouth ATL OF
(It's a keeper, so ARod upgrade at 3B was my goal. My closer depth is Soriano/Street/Perez without Gonzalez now.)

I traded Nolasco FLA SP/Strasburg WAS SP for J.Johnson FLA SP.
(I felt like I needed an ace with Hanson/Peavy as the top starters on my staff.)


That's the five trades I've made thus far in my fantasy baseball season, how did I do? What trades seem like reaches for me?

AaronG · Accepted Answer

Trade 1= Chad is better
Trade 2= Upton has higher upside
Trade 3= Its close but Reynolds wins (just because ill usually take hitting over pitching)
Trade 4= A-Rod side wins, its really not even close.
Trade 5= Nolasco side wins, im not high on rookies at all.

Seems like you did a pretty good job overall.

Anonymous · Answer

Awwww... i imagine your giving up too a lot. Strasburg from what we've considered so a ideas is basically to sturdy to commerce. Haren pitches in between the most acceptable hitter's parks contained in the league so even extra reason this isn't the most excellent commerce. although, Hamilton is the most well-loved hitter in baseball. See in case you will get Hamilton rapidly-up for Cruz if this commerce hasn't been known yet. success to you on your fantasy endeavors.

Rate these Fantasy Baseball trades? (5 trades in 4 different leagues)?

2 Answers