Which of this years american idol contestants do you like best and why? Who would you have sent home by now?

Question

im just getting caught up on my american idol. i have pretty much not watched it like i used to for a few years. 

i kind of feel like i should be the only one allowed to vote lol a lot of good people leave imo

lilly scott was one of my top favs and when she left i was just like "wtf? there must be tweeners voting or something" seriously good taste is laking and a lot of the viewers are such little kids who have no taste. no offense to anyone just how i feel. 

siobhan (i think im spelling it right...lol) is one of my favs. love love love her. then comes crystal, casey james, big mike. 

the others are just okay for me. lee was so not memorable for me until that "treat her like a lady" song. i did love didi's version of rhiannon. i love that song and her voice was so beautiful in it. recap cuz its awesome :)  :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdH77FZanAs&feature=related

i thought hailey was adorable but she needs to grow like the judges said. 

i think katie and paige had two of the best voices but neither of them seem to know what to do with it. honestly i hate how the judges tell katie to be more young and contemporary. if she likes older music and wants a more mature image she should be able to embrace that and not change who she is. then they turn around and say "find who you are." gah. 

and how awesome is ellen on this show? shes so freakin funny. i was upset about what happened to paula and i still think it wasnt fair but eh. ellen beats her. :)

if i had control tim urban, andrew garcia, and probably lee would have gone home already instead of lacey brown, lilly scott, and paige. 

what about yooouuu?? :)

Ashlee:) · Accepted Answer

Tim Urban, because he's H O T hot!

quaker · Answer

My favorites are: a million)Aaron, he received't have the biggest voice of the bunch yet i respect his sweet usa voice 2)Lee, his voice is great.. he jogs my memory of David cook 3)Crystal, she has spectacular vocals 4)Casey, he's a large performer. I also like Michael because of his impressive enormous voice, yet his form of song would not rather attraction to me, i'm no longer rather into R&B/Soul. And those are the human beings i desire eradicated.. a million)Tim, he ought to've been eradicated weeks in the past, he sucks! 2)Siobhan, her screaming is so overrated.. i imagine the judges and the human beings would not like her as a lot if she did not scream in her performances. Her screaming is annoying and screechy, it would not sound solid, compared to Adam Lambert's. 3)Katie, she has solid vocals yet her performances are extremely weak for my section. 4) Andrew - Ugh, i don't love him in any respect.. he's overrated! My appropriate finale may be Lee-Aaron.. it must be like David-David, lol.

Rachel · Answer

I really liked Alex Lambert, he was just a little shy -- but GREAT voice.
I'm also a fan of Andrew Garcia (I know --yuck) but, hes good! I love how he plays the guitar!
I honestly think they need to stop comparing every performance to his "Straight Up" performance.

TIM URBAN NEEDS TO FALL IN A HOLE.

I liked Lacey Brown, too. I think she had a really unique voice.

(R) Sarah · Answer

I love Andrew Garcia. He's pretty legit. 
Tim needs to leave... the Disney Channel would gladly take him. In other words, he sucks.

Ducky · Answer

Tim needs to GO already! 
I am rooting for Aaron and Casey

Trending News

Which of this years american idol contestants do you like best and why? Who would you have sent home by now?

5 Answers