WOuld u accept thiS Fantasy Baseball Trade?

I would have to say no - as tempting as this offer sounds. Either fielder to Holliday and Hernandez to Halladay is a downgrade.

What I've learned over the years about fantasy baseball...never trade off the best.

Wow. That's actually a decent trade offer.

I wonder what kind of league you're in. If you're in a H2H points or categories I'd say do it! You may be downgrading a notch at pitcher, you'll still get solid wins, K's, ERA and innings. Cruz and Granderson together will give you plenty of HR's, RBI's, but Cruz has the potential to hurt your AVG.

If you're in a roto league, I'd probably stick with what you have because of just how well rounded in all stats both Holliday and Halladay are.

Take the trade...it is a plus because you get Cruz to offset the fact that Roy is a little better than Felix. Curtis I think will be as good if not better than Holiday .

that's no longer even close. No commerce. Navarro is an excellent catcherbut Harden if greater effective than Lilly and Fielder is greater effective at his place than Navarro. i'm thinking in case you have a 1B already and consequently you're even watching this commerce? if so, you additionally could make a greater effective deal than this one. you will hit upon a back-up on the FA checklist.

yeah,i love that move......

at the end of the yr,Halladay will have a few more wins than Felix,but the numbers will be very similar......and i think Holliday is a bit overrated......Cruz will end up w/ more HR's AND RBI''s.....and Granderson will also have more HR's,plus more triples and SB's.......

i think its great move.....i would jump all over it.

I like it you are getting three top 50 players for two top 30 players and I'll take high quality depth every time.

I strongly agree with the guy who answered first i would just keep what you got