When will you kids wake up and realize American Idol is a singing competition not a?

I agree, Tim Urban CAN'T sing.

But Aaron can, and even if it's not about the "hotness" factor, it is about connecting with the audience and about the song choice and he does that well.

i agree with 'i <3 naps'...

i'm a teenager and i never voted for tim. i'm a huge fan of lee and i'd like to see him go as far as possible, based on his singing. yes, lee is good looking but that's not the reason i vote for him, it's just the icing on the cake. and besides, there are only two stand out contestants this year, so something needs to happen with all the rest of the lousy singers. they can't send tim, siobhan, mike, casey, and aaron home all at the same time, it's gotta go week by week (note how i didn't mention lee or crystal, hence they are the best). and yes, crystal is great, but i like lee more and i think he appeals to a larger audience and more people would buy his music today.

Oh oh someone is in a bad mood. Leave them alone. If the people on here want to adore someone so be it. Who cares. That's what it is all about. Entertainment and whatever that means to some people is fine. I think Casey is kind of hot myself. AI is a personality contest too. Not just singing. No ugly people on there.

Uh, whatever, I like Tim. He wasn't even that bad of a singer.

And no, I won't be voting for Aaron. He is NOT next on the "hotness meter".

I wouldn't say kids are careing tabout this kind of stuff because nobody really cares fir American idol much anymore. It's mainly who the producers and directors decide to leave on the show because of their high ratings. Like on DWTS, Kate gosslin should have been the first one to go but they know people are going to watch the show to see you mess up so they won't kick her off.

for many of this season, i presumed the tutor became transforming into extra of a acceptance contest, fairly for the reason that Tim city stayed for see you later, whilst extra suitable singers have been being sent abode. yet because of the fact the tutor ended up coming right down to 2 actual singer/songwriter/musicians, i think of expertise ended up triumphing interior the tip.

Tim Urban sucks, thank god he's finally off!!

Crystal is the best!

i'm a teenager and i totally agree that tim got to top 7 only on the "hotness" factor. imo, he's fugly. his bulging eyes are creepy, and his cheesy smile made me gag everytime. i hated tim's guts! i'm rooting for is lee.. great voice, style and he's improving every week!

And Crystal is the only one there who can really sing!