Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 4

Is this the proof we can use to finally disprove God?

I know it looks like a lot, but please read it and try to understand...

For Heaven to exist, and be both infinite and eternal, it must exist outside space and time (beyond the Universe). Therefore, there is no physical matter there, as having matter creates mass and gravity, thereby creating space and time. Energy is not made of particles, it is a capacity to work and therefore has no physical mass. So it can exist outside this realm. All good and well so far.

Your soul is contained within your consciousness, so it is not your soul, but your consciousness that goes into heaven. Your consciousness comes from electrical energy in the brain, movement of charged particles around your synapses. It is impossible for this consciousness to exist outside space/time because electrical energy is carried by charged sub-atomic particles which have mass. To take these outside space/time would create mass and gravity, and thereby space and time. The same goes for hell. Therefore, the idea of your soul going to heaven/hell is impossible.

God would also have to have a consciousness in order to use the energy at his disposal in heaven and, as I've just explained, consciousness outside space/time is impossible. Thus God is impossible.

Do you see now?

23 Answers

Relevance
  • Andy D
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Your physics is weak

    1) There are so many theories of multiverses, brane theory, multiple dimensions, string theory that you cannot dismiss 'outside' our physical universe so lightly. Hence

    2) Electrical current is carried by massive charged particles (electrons) electric fields are mediated by massless particles (photons). There are plenty of fields that we do not understand yet - e.g. the Higgs field as a source of mass.

    3) You make the reductionist assumption that all human experience and behaviour must necessarily be reduced to electrical impulses in the brain. This is not proof.

    I am not a religious believer but you need to come up with something better than this, so the answer is NO

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    Science does not and never will address the existence or non-existence of God. The "God Particle" was named by the Press, in spite of numerous scientists objecting that it never had anything to do with God, and should be referred to simply as "Higgs-Boson." The Theory of Evolution does not disprove God, either, although it might interfere with the Genesis story in the Bible, and be problematic to Bible literalists. The Big Bang Theory does not disprove God, and science has always reminded us that we cannot know what existed even one minute before the Big Bang. String Theory and Membrane Theory also cannot address previous conditions. In the question of the existence of the Divine, science simply will not go there.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    nope.

    energy is only a capacity to work in a physical environment(so in other words, you're using black to deny the existence of white). in a non-physical environment, it's a relation.

    prove that infinity and eternity MUST exist outside space and time. (explain the difference between time, space, and spacetime, please).

    soul is not "contained" within consciousness, but is a separate unit of a universal state of awareness.

    consciousness doesn't come from energy, but is an expression of a form of energy. (relation).

    you say consciousness has mass and gravity, and then you say to take consciousness outside space/time creates mass and gravity; not logical. to take consciousness strips it only of mass and gravity, but not of essence or of relation (energy).

    i'll stop there because i gotta go to the can, but sorry, smartie.

    epic fail.

  • 1 decade ago

    God is beyond science, so how can you use science to disprove him, God was the one who created the laws of nature.

    You say you don't believe in God but it will be a sad thing if you find out that your wrong when he returns to this world, by then it will be too late.

    Hayden instead PLEASE!!!!!! I'm begging you to realize that God is real and accept him as your saviour before it's too late to repent.

    Jesus said this 2000 thousand years ago in the last days men will become lovers of themselves, boastful, unthankful, unholy, walking after their own lust. They will become lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God.

    Jesus also said there will be wars and rumors of wars, there will be earthquakes here and there. Knowledge will increase and men will run to and fro.

    The heart of man will become desperately wicked. These are all things Juses said would happen, they will be sure signs that you are living in the last days of earth, very close to when Jesus will return as the conquering lion of Judah.

    He's coming back for all who believe in him and Jesus wants you to be one of those people who followed him.

    If Jesus was not the son of God then he wouldn't have been able to tell his disciples what will happen 2000 years from the time they were alive. There are so many things that point to why God does exist but your ignoring them. The Seventh Day Adventist Church is where I hope you will go. Please think about all I've just said.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    Yes i do see yet religious people will still say that god and heaven can not be so easily cast out from that theory because you cant know there is no science behind it. You could go back in time and watch the human race form see the person that came up with the bible and they could tell you that its all a lie and the would still believe because they live so blindly that they don't care about fact because god is so fathomable that you can't think of what he is because you could never see the truth hes that great.

    I'm with you your theory works for me.

  • Nice try, but there are plenty of particles that have been observed without mass.

    God heaven and hell are unfalsifiable, and therefore science will *never* disprove God and will never attempt to (seriously anyway).

  • 1 decade ago

    Unsupported assertions are not proof of anything.

    Stop trying to disprove god. You can't do it, because all someone has to do is say, "no, no, that's not my definition of god."

    Instead, you should be focusing on examining and refuting specific claims about god(s). If the person making the claim cannot back it up with evidence, then you can reject it. You don't have to prove they are wrong.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    It's impossible to disprove god like it's impossoble to disprove that giant space bunnies exist in parallel universe. Applying science to religion doesn't work.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    The theory of god was created by cavemen who needed to explain mother nature.

    Imagine how it must have been to experience rain, lightning, and earthquakes with no kind of knowledge or scientific explanation.

  • Friend,

    Please leave God to HIMSELF for at least six months and try to read some thing about HIm.

    Then come back and post a question, if you feel you really have some thing to ask.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.