Which CSI is better, and more realistic, CSI New York or Miami?

CSI New York is far more realistic because it takes into account the real dynamics concerning crime and capture under new york state jurdistriction. Additionally, the cases are more down to Earth and actually took place (in a deviated point) at some point in New York History. As for better, I would say Miami because it's got more action, more drama, and thrill however it's cases are loosely based on what some would call "real" facts. If you ask me, not so much. So If you want pure entertainment, watch Miami but if you want realism and a good mix of thrill and down to earthness...stick to new york.

CSI: Crime Scene study (additionally prevalent as Vegas) is the appropriate and the closest to what i think of genuine CSI's do. meaning they do no longer tell the known law enforcement officials what to do like Caine does in CSI Miami. and that they do no longer go busting into rooms with weapons out like CSI ny. CSI Miami could be greater useful without David Caruso (Horatio Caine). relax of the solid is physically powerful, yet Wolfe is in simple terms ok. CSI ny desires much less hokey storylines, yet there have been some reliable ones this 12 months. reliable characters & great appearing.

I like the original. Miami is just the David Caruso show "takes off sunglasses". But let's face it, they're not realistic. CSI's don't investigate crimes. They are not detectives. they don't go around questioning suspects & getting involved in shootouts. That's the police.

The most realistic CSI (if you ignore her goth look & tatoos) is Abby on NCIS. She never leaves the lab, just does her lab work. That's what most, if not all do. You know, like Wendy on theoriginal CSI.

Miami, last episode of NY there was a really unrealistic thing that left me at a confused state in my mind

I liked Las Vegas the best of them all.