should I trade Larry Fitzgerald and Reggie Bush for Sidney Rice and Pierre Thomas?

I would do the trade...

Put it into perspective:

Bush is not going to get the majority of the carries vs. Thomas.

Rice is coming off an injury but still is valuable especially in Minnesota and the offense they run. Fitzgerald will put up comparable numbers (maybe slightly higher).

However a running back is gonna get more points in the long run. They get the majority of the carries close to the end-zone and more touches than a wide out does.

I would do the trade

This is a hard one, But in the Long run, Pierre Thomas rules this trade. Fitzgerald lost Warner, Which Means 2 things. They will want to run the ball a lot more, and Leinart is no where near the talent of warner. He will also have to share receptions with Anquan Boldin. And you never know with first year QB's, he could feel a strong connection with Boldin over Fitz, Kind of Like Miles Austin. Sidney Rice at least has Brett Favre, but i have to think with his age Peterson should be stealing alot more time. Way more INT are coming in Favre's way. But still i would go with Rice over Fitz just to be safe. And then it's as simple as Thomas is the starter, Bush is not. Thomas If healthy the entire year, which i think he will manage to do, will get alot more time than Bush. I think alot of people over look the time Bush Gets. even last year when Thomas was out, Mike Bell had near numbers to Bush. So with all that said, you are getting the better deal, or should i say, an improvement at RB. Good Luck!

According to a trade analyzer Fitz and Bush have more value. Fitz is a really shaky pick this year because Matt Leniert could be anywhere on the skill level. Fitzgerald will probably be more like a Brandon Marshall, a talented receiver with an okay QB. As for Bush and Thomas I think it will be a pretty close year for them. So your pretty much asking who will do better, Rice or Fitzgerald. I believe with the return of Favre that Rice will have a better fantasy year then Fitzgerald.

definitely Fitzgerald. Sidney Rice had a great 12 months and that i do think of that he's respectable, yet Larry Fitzgerald has shown that he's an elite wideout. Rice might have greater long distance speed than Fitz, yet he isn't as actual and is not somewhat as stable at in simple terms going up and beating a DB for a pass.

I would definitely do it! Larry is going down since Warner retired, Sidney's season is going to be similar to last year since Farve is back, and Pierre Thomas for Bush is a no-brainer. Definitely do it!

I would do it for sure, with favre back rice will do good, lienart will hurt fitzgerald... And pierre will do better than bush