who would you rather draft percy harvin? jeremy maclin or mike sims-walker?

Mike Sims Walker\. Hes a #1 WR on JAX with no one that will challange him as the go to guy.

Maclin is a #2 WR in PHI who i think will have a great year but not as good as SIMS WALKER with Jackson holding him back a bit.

Harvin a #2 WR and if stays healthy will be the #1 for atl east first 8 weeks. Concerned about the Migranes with him

Best of Luck :D

Keeper league?

Harvin for sure, no contest.

He is only in his second season, and if he can get the migranes under control will be huge for the Vikings no matter who is at quarterback.

Sims Walker is good, but has a very shakey quarterback, and Maclin has potential, but has proved nothing yet.

although your in a keeper league and a return league, i would still have to go with sims walker. he is the #1 in jacksonville and is projected to have around 1000 yds recieving, which is reasonable considering he i the only known wideout on the team. remember, garrard did make the pro bowl last season even though he was a 2nd alternate.

harbins condition seems pretty serious so its unknown how many games he will miss this season. also we dont even know if favre will return next year or if he can continue his success from last year

i think simswalker is the safe choice.

If you get any kind of return points, Harvin for sure. MSW if not.