If someone tells you a secret and you tell someone the secret but dont say who?

Question

is it alright
if someone tells you a secret
and you tell someone the secret but dont say who?
saying: this girl i know __________. or i have a friend who __________.
and its impossible for them 2 even geuss right?


what do you think?
p.s. is this wrong? does that make you a bad friend?

h a n · Accepted Answer

yes.....

Anonymous · Answer

Well at least you kept it anonymous. The only way I see it being bad is if the person you told the secret to can figure out who the person with the secret is.

♥ƒυηку~gιяℓ♥ &lt;give me a second go&gt; · Answer

I did that once, and then they asked me "Who?" and I didn't respond.
I felt so guilty, even though they didn't know who I was talking about.

I won't do that again! A secret is a secret, and they shouldn't even be told anonymously.

mollygirl! · Answer

personally i think its okay.. it is no longer a secret but at least they dont know who its about.

Anonymous · Answer

its somewhat wrong as he or she will eventually find out...but on the other hand u can have many friends and they wont know.


but also remember thats how rumors start.

BeachBum · Answer

No if you promise not to tell that means you will not tell.. bottom line

Anonymous · Answer

yes it's wrong and completely ridiculous

? · Answer

shot in the dark but....you're still in elementary?

Anonymous · Answer

they're just pyschic, ok...

Trending News

If someone tells you a secret and you tell someone the secret but dont say who?

9 Answers