Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Why Kashmiris are not demanding parts controlled by China be returned.?

Some of them may hate India and some of them may love Pakistan. But surely China can never be acceptable to any Kashmiri.

16 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Kashmiri Pundits must ask that. They must not be so selfish that they talk of them only & never criticise Indian military doing all sorts of human rights violations in Kashmir Valley by killing > 7,00,000(8 times more than Pundits' total population in the valley) innocent Muslims & raping thousands of young girls , indulging looting, extortion, arson, death & destruction putting entire valley under brutality, imperialism & colonialism. They want flesh pound but never support elimination of genuine problems of Kashmiri Muslims, the 97 % population of the valley.

    The area under China is 17 % & population of that being < 10 % total population of the state.

    That area too is DISPUTED as Jammu, Ladakh, Kashmir Valley, Azad Kashmir, Gilgit & Baltistan , as it is very clear from UNSC Resolution dated 21 st April, 1948.

    During TEMPORARY agreement between Pakistan & China in 1963 about demarcation of common boundary in northern areas of the state, it is clearly written that it will be treated as temporary one subject to FINAL SOLUTION OF THE STATE'S PROBLEM between India & Pakistan as per UNSC Resolutions dated 5 th January, 1949 & 24 th January, 1957. After solution of that problem, China will negotiate with the nation having common boundary with China. So, decision of that is WAITING FINAL SOLUTION OF KASHMIR DISPUTE between India, Pakistan & MOST IMPORTANTLY, the PEOPLE of the state.

    Demand can be made diplomatically by putting all solid LEGAL documents across the table, as any claiming nation has right to present one's case as per UN Charter. Kashmiris are demanding first the solution of the BIGGEST & MOST IMPORTANT problem. After that, such SMALL things will be managed IN NO TIME.

    As far as I know the history, China invaded India in 1962 only to secure Aksai Chin of Ladakh to connect Tibet with Xinjiang by roads which she did within 2 weeks after ceasefire speedily. In most favourable solution for India too, China will not vacate the area east of the road & for a bargain for that only perhaps, she unilaterally vacated entire are from NEFA(arunachal Pradesh) to Tezpur of Meghalaya immediately after ceasefire & asked Nehru to visit China for meaningful negotiations. Later, China, returned all Indian POWs & agains asked him fornegotiations. Arrogant Nehru was still adamant. So, she sent message, "India, go to the hell."

    If you collect records, there is nothing available before British documented records anywhere either on eastern border or western one with China to CLEARLY DEMARCATE boundaries, as Shashi Tharoor too said recently on TV. How will you claim then ?

  • 1 decade ago

    It was Pakistan who ceded some part of Erstwhile J&K to China in settlement of their( Pakistan/China) border dispute. And J&K as it stood in 1948 is a part and parcel of Indian Union. Kashmir dispute is between India and Pakistan and Kashmiris claim that they should be a party to the dispute. But if Pakistan and India settle the dispute in one way or the other, Kashmiris have no any say in it, because they were voting in all the Assembly Elections conducted by the Government of India in Kashmir and many State governments have came and gone in J&K, and even today alegally elected Govt is governing that state. So the people of that region are Indian Citizens. They have no separate identity as Kashmiris. They are at par with Tamils, Assamese,Malayalees etc etc.

    So coming to the point, India has to take back the part given to China in a tipartite talk or Pakistan should return the same land or similar land area from their land while returning the POK to India in settlement of J&K dispute sooner or later. India should be happy with that settlement.

    Source(s): Self
  • 1 decade ago

    China is gifted part of pakistan occupied kashmir by Pakistan not by Kashmiri!s.Admiral V K Singh

  • 1 decade ago

    They won’t. They only know to fight against Indian Government because they are misguided by their wrong consideration of their own religion. They even are not going to help Leh!! Make a note about their mentality! They do not want Kashmir. They are mad only for green coloured land. Kashmiriyat is not for Kashmiri pundits. So, how then they will worry about the illegal donation of the piece of mother land to China?

    Source(s): A journalist asked a waiter boy in Srinagar about why their people want to be separated from India? What they will get in Pakistan? He answered “ Idhar sab kuch sasta hai saab. Pakistan main itana accha nahi hai. Par Hari zandi ka bhi kuch Khayaal Karna chahiye ya nahi?”
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    Some Kashmiris are misusing their democratic rights which they can't even dream in the rotten countries like China and Pakistan.Their fate will be the same as that of Uyghurs,Tibetans,Baluchis.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    OOOOPS, to be fair India should be doing that and not Kashmiris, so get that right. It is common sense that since Kashmir is part of India and therefore India ought to claim it back.

    So, now that the shoe is on the other foot, what is your opinion on this?

    Are we saying China is the reason and India is **** scared?

    What do you say to that Momamama what ever?

    http://factsanddetails.com/china.php?itemid=294&ca...

  • 1 decade ago

    The area occupied by China in the State of Jammu & Kashmir belong to the Republic of India, and it is the concern of the Government of India to safe guard.

  • Of course the censored information do not reach us. So called Azad Kashmir as well as China occupied Kashmir both are under censorship of the the respective governments, and media and human rights watchdogs are not allowed to report on that region, we really do not know what is happening in those regions. This is really pathetic that our government allow these separatists to speak thus they speak crap, but they don't care to speak about those regions.

  • 1 decade ago

    They are very well aware about mighty china. They will bark against India only because of tolerance hardwired in Indian culture.

  • 1 decade ago

    In India they face rubber bullets,but in China real bullets.Fear of Life

    Source(s): Tiananmen Square
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.