Would you do this trade?

your dont need another rb

I would NOT advise you to make that trade. First of all, Collie has been suffering an injury that has caused him to be the most productive in INDY. Well, aside from last weeks FG fiesta Indy has been sending it Collies way. McFadden has NOT proven himself to be more valuable than Collie at this point. try Free Agency.. need an RB pick up torrain, and have Darby on Standby.

hard to say, if mcfadden were healthy I'd do it in a second. looks like maybe this week out, and he'll be back after that. that said crabtree could be decent #3 receiver until Rice plays. If you believe in Rice performing well as soon as hes back I still do trade now. with your current RB's your playing guessing games each week. mcfadden would solve that. if i had a crappy record trying to save season, i do it.

idk both are about the same mcfadden now splitting carries with bush so i would keep collie