Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 4
? asked in Business & FinanceTaxesUnited States · 1 decade ago

Claim siblings for 2010 taxes?

So I claimed my little sister last year and my mom claimed my brother because we both kept up the cost of household expenses 50/50. This year however my mom got laid off and is on ui benefits. I was reading on the IRS websites and I came to the conclusion that I can claim both my brother and sister because my AGI was considerably higher than my moms and all her income was unearned because they were ui benefits. Unfortunately it looks like I can't claim my mom because she made over 3650, I want to know if there is an exception to this rule. I paid the rent, cable, internet, phone, credit cards, etc. My mom is only getting 95.00 a week which is scrap money. I made 300 to 400 a week. Since I claimed my sister last year I shouldn't have problems but I heard the IRS loves to pick out returns if you claim more than one dependent, I really don't care if they audit me because I don't have anything to hide and they are my qualifying relatives, however we need that income tax refund pretty fast and wouldn't want a delay. Please let me know if any of you have had a similar situation. Thanks in advance!!

6 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Assuming your siblings are younger than you and otherwise meet the qualifications of being a qualifying child (age, residency, support, etc.), either you or your mother can claim your siblings. Under the tax code, your mother has a superior claim since she is the parent. If your mother wants to claim your siblings (though I don't know why she would) she is allowed to do so and you cannot. If your mother chooses not to claim your siblings, under the special test for qualifying child of more than one person you should be able to claim both of your siblings as a qualifying child with little problem. There could be an audit, but you look sound to me.

    Source(s): IRS Pub. 17
  • 1 decade ago

    There is an exception to the $3650 rule for income that disabled person receive working in a sheltered workshop. There is no exception to the $3650 rule for a "qualifying relative" when the income is UI benefits. The $3650 rule does not apply if your mother is your "qualifying child" (which might be theoretically possible if you were older than your "mother" and there was some convoluted situation involving stepparents, adoption, etc., but I tend to doubt that is what happened.)

    Claiming more than one dependent is not unusual and usually does not cause an audit if (1) you are an adult, (2) both dependents are children, and (3) no one else tries to claim the same dependents.

    It might make sense to rework the numbers so that you can say you paid 50.001% and she paid 49.999%, instead of 50.000-50.000. There is no way to prove or disprove a 0.001% difference and claiming that you paid over 50% and claiming a dependent may allow you to file as "HOH" instead of "single".

  • Judy
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    If you both claimed HofH last year (I'm guessing maybe you did from your comment about keeping expenses 50-50) then you both filed illegally. HofH requires that you pay MORE THAN half the expenses - if you kept it 50-50, neither of you paid MORE than half.

    That said, you can very possibly claim your siblings this year if they're both younger than you, but NOT your mom, no there is no exception to the $3650 income. And just because you claimed your sis last year doesn't mean you don't get questioned this year.

  • Squirt
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    There should be no reason for you not to take the siblings on your taxes. Be sure that your mother does not claim them. If she has only unemployment income, that is not considered earned income and therefore would not be able to get the earned income credit or child tax credits. So Absolutely claim the kids and get the credits if you can qualify for them.

    I pray that things get better for you in 2011

    Source(s): mom
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    The IRS changed the rules in 2005 and updated those changes later.

    In order for you to claim one or more siblings, you had to be *older* than your sibling (you were) *and* have higher income than your mom. This is in ADDITION to living with mom and sis all year.

    By the way, splitting costs 50/50 means neither you nor your mom will be eligible for HOH filing status.

  • tro
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    qualifying children are those directly related to you, under your age, you are providing more than 50% of their support and the resided in your household 6 months

    your siblings are not a problem

    picking out returns due to the number of dependents is not one of the 'difs' used to determine which return will be audited

    the qualifying relative rule is set in stone, no exceptions

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.