Fantasy Baseball Keepers? Need Help Picking.?

I say stay with hanley, votto, upton and mccutcheon and keep uggla. I am assuming that phillips and utley would be kept as well which leaves not many better options at 2b. weeks is comparable but last year was the first time in 6 seasons he's managed to stay healthy all year. uggla has been healthy and consistent throughout his career.

you don't need fielder, you already have votto for 1b. you would have 2 of the 3 thin infield positions covered and only leaves you with a hole to fill @ 3b.

top pitching is deeper in the NL than the AL and you can probably get latos or better back in the first or second round if you wanted to.

Would you not be allowed to keep those NL players from last year who are now on AL teams (Reynolds, Haren)?

Votto, Hanley are first rounders, no question they must be kept.

I'm not as high on McCutchen as you seem to be, I would pass on keeping him, also because I feel that there is more OF depth than there is at certain IF positions.

The players Im considering for your last 3 spots are Latos, Johnson, Uggla, Fielder, Upton.

To me, I'd skip on Upton and Uggla as I fear they'll both rocket back to the earth with AVGs of .250. I like the young pitching duo of Latos and Johnson and Fielder just has too much upside in Milwaukee to let him fall off the face of the earth just yet, especially in an NL only.

Great team though, some tough choices, Good luck!

Hanley, Votto, JJ, and Latos, and Haren

I wouldnt keep cutch or upton because there are a lot of good outfielders. Dont keep fielder either because first base is really deep also. Uggla is good, but there are other second baseman like rickie weeks that will put up similar numbers. Reynold strikes out way too much to be a keeper.

i would not save the two Tulo and Reyes. save Tulowitzki, McCutchen, and Encarnacion. attempt to commerce Reyes for a draft p.c.. or a SP properly worth retaining. possibly a Matt Cain or David cost. in case you are able to pull off a commerce, then drop Encarnacion.