Who should be the top five starting pitchers in a MLB fastasy baseball draft?

1. Roy Halladay PHI SP

2. Felix Hernandez SEA SP

3. Tim Lincecum SFG SP

4. Jon Lester BOS SP

5. C.C. Sabathia NYY SP

(Cliff Lee and Ubaldo Jimenez would be #6 and #7)

You can't count Gallardo in the top 5 pitchers, period. He always has control issues or health problems that keep him from having a Cy Young calibur season, the good thing is he can strikeout batters well. Kershaw's still coming into his prime, but would round out inside the top 10 certainly. Greinke is another who would make it at the back end of the top ten with the likes of David Price, but is injured right now so we'll see how he progresses.

Good question, hope this helped!

in the journey that your no longer purely speaking of pitchers in 2008 and going via their careers then no longer a million of the pitchers on your checklist belong there in the present day. no longer that they do no longer look to be reliable pitchers, basically plenty extra desirable careers nonetheless enjoying baseball. those could be my appropriate 5. a million - Greg Maddux 2 - Randy Johnson 3 - Pedro Martinez 4 - Tom Glavine 5 - John Smoltz To me it variety of sounds like a quite good form of youthful each physique is answering this question via fact all 5 of the adult men i've got indexed would be in the hall of popularity and not a million of them is on each physique's checklist. while you're speaking approximately terrific pitchers over say the final 5 years then your checklist could be a incredibly reliable checklist. My appropriate 5 over the final 5 years could look like this. a million - Josh Beckett - Ace of the pitching team for international sequence triumphing communities in 2003, 2004, and 2007. 2 - Brandon Webb - Severly underrated and has basically nasty stuff. 3 - Roy Halladay - He can bypass the gap extra then the different pitcher in the completed league. he's yet another severly underrated pitcher. 4 - Johan Santana - till going to the Mets this 365 days he might have been appropriate on my checklist, yet he has basically been beat up along with his transition to the nationwide League. 5 - Carlos Zambrano - a quite good form of people hate him and think of he's puffed up. certainty is he's hardly injured and supply you each thing he's have been given while he's on the mound, to no longer point out he's often in direction of the tops in ok's 365 days after 365 days.