Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

? asked in Science & MathematicsPhysics · 1 decade ago

Estimating the Height of a Building from Another Building?

Let's say you're on the 50th floor of a building, and you can see some buildings below. How do you estimate the height of the buildings below, as accurately as possible?

How about when you want to estimate the height of a skyscraper, which is taller than where you are? Can the same method be used?

Update:

Truestory,

Assume you don't know how high you're. And you don't have specialty equipments like theodolite; i.e., what do you use instead?

Please specify what "the angle subtended by the bottom and top of the building" is in your 1st paragraph.

Please explain further about your 3rd paragraph. How do you know the horizontal distance?

And once you know the horizontal distance between the 2 buildings, how do you know the height of the building below?

For the 2nd question, you're on the 50th floor and the skyscraper is taller. If that makes a difference.

Update 2:

Mrs Thievery,

This is one of those random questions I thought up.

As for the equipment, assume you're in an arbitrary building. You're likely to have a cell phone with you, so you can use calculator, stopwatch, internet, etc in it. In short, what you usually carry with you, and something you can find in any building, e.g., fire extinguisher, are allowed. I think a person doesn't usually carry a tape measure. You may be able to improvise with other things, however.

Never mind dropping things, you could kill pedestrians.

I can't imagine your echo method. Does it work like when you scream in the mountain?

Regarding your "compare the height" method, I wonder how to reconcile the fact that you're looking from above. In other words, you can only see the roof of a car, the top of a street lamp, etc. But I think this works when the buildings are far apart, and you have very good eyes (not me). In fact, I thought about the same thing when I thought up this question. Oh, and I don't under

Update 3:

-stand what "a computer in a window" is. Please explain?

Update 4:

Truestory,

Oh, I got it. Thank you for the explanation. I think you meant:

Height = Horizontal Distance*( tan(beta) - tan(alpha) )

So a question remains:

How do we estimate the height of one story, and roof, etc, from the 50th floor?

Update 5:

Truestory,

Oh, you're refering to the case when the building we're measuring is taller than where we're. When I initially read your explanation, I imagined a case when it's shorter. But now I notice it makes more sense when read with the taller building in mind.

I see that this question is seemingly impossible. But I wonder if anyone can figure this out.

2 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    you need an instrument (e.g. theodolite) to measure the angle subtended by the bottom and top of the building. once you know this angle and the horizontal distance between the building and you, you can use basic trignometric funtion like 'tan' to measure the height of the building.

    yes, the same method can be used to estimate the height of the building when you standing on the ground.

    if the building is very far to measure the horizontal distance from you. you can follow the above mentioned procedures at two different locations and by measuring the distance between these two locations ( e.g. 10 metres) and basic trignometric calculations you can find the height of the building.

    edited after additional details:

    angle subtended: imagine a line from the top of the building to the point where you are standing. imagine another line from the bottom of the building and the same point, so that it intersects. now the angle between these two lines is the angle subtended by the building. you can divide this angle into: angle between top of the building and the horizontal, say 'alpha'; and angle between bottom of the building and the horizontal, say 'beta'. if you can somehow find the distance between the other building and the point where you are standing (horizontal distance....you can use a tape to measure the distance between the base of the two buildings), then height of the building = horz. distance * (tan(alpha) + tan(beta))

    note: horiz. distance * tan(alpha) gives height of the building above your level.

    horiz. distance * tan(beta) gives height of the building below your level.

    you just have to add these two values to get the total height.

    you formula containing -ve sign is valid if you are considering angle beta as -ve, which will make -tan(beta) +ve.

    if you dont have any instruments, the best you can do is measure the no. of floors and multiply it with the approximate height of each floor. also accounting for slab thickness.

    the height of each story can in turn be measure by multiplying number of steps in the stair case and rise of each step. this is very easy to calculate and yields fairly accurate result. you don't have to account for roof thickness since it's already covered. of course, with an assumption that each story is of same height.

    but, if you just want to measure the height of another building without any instruments, or knowing the horizontal distance, or having access to it's staircase, i am afraid there is no way of doing it.

    Source(s): Doing my masters in civil engineering at IIT Madras.
  • 1 decade ago

    Interesting.. is this a question you have an answer to already and are testing us? or do you want to know?

    When you say you have no special equipment, what do you mean? Absolutely nothing? Do you have things like a tape measure, a stopwatch, a calculator?

    You could drop something large off the building you are on and time its fall till the ground work out your height... repeat for better accuracy.

    If you have a spirit level and a tape measure you can estimate the angle between horizontal at your position and the top of the opposite building relatively accurately.

    Measuring the horizontal distance between you and the other building will be the most difficult. If the other building is taller and not too far away you could potentially create a loud noise and time until you hear the echo. then knowing the speed of sound in air you could get an estimate. from there you could calculate the height of the other building.

    I think the easiest way would be to find a common object of known height next to a floor (eg a car on the street next to the building, a road sign, a computer in a window) then use this to estimate the height of a single floor. Then count the number of floors and multiply.. you'd have to estimate extras like the roof etc. Probably could get it suprisingly accurate as most skyscrapers are very regular buildings.. be a lot quicker too.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.