Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Guy problems. Which guy should I chose?

Guy number one:

Most quality guy I have ever met. Seriously the nicest, most considerate person I have ever met. From the day i met him i just wanted to become closer to him because I could tell that he is an amazing person inside in out. I am not really sure if i could see a relationship with him simply because he isn't really smooth and is slightly awkward around girls and I would never be able to tell if he was seriously interested (he flirts a lot with me via text and we've watched movies together, but he is nice to a lot of girls), but I know if I were to date him, I would never get hurt and it would be the perfect relationship.

Guy number 2:

oh man oh man. this guy I was immediately attracted too. He is the perfect flirt and we had this thing during the end of the year, but his history is messy. Friends with benefits wiht one girl who screwed him over and i feel like he still has feelings for her, and then he is simply a flirt and i feel like is easily attracted to new things. But he is such a deep person. Our conversations can go from philosophical to just messing around and having fun and i like that. clearly this is the guy im more into, but im not going to lie, ive never been hurt before or been in a real relationship. i can see this guy unintentionaly hurting me. he wouldn't screw me over and play me, but i can see him simply getting interested in other girls and ending any relationship. its summer, so ive been distancing myself from him, trying to make sure i dont get hurt. hes not a player, hes a geunine guy, but i feel like i will get hurt, and i dont want that for myself. i have always guarded myself and have been fine with that. maybe thats why ive never had a real relationship, but thats never really bothered me. to be honest i dont know if a relatinoship with him would be worth the hurt, especially when i know i have a more quality guy that wouldnt do that to me. But i know guy number two is the one i want to be with more.

Btw, if i were to commit to guy number one, guy number two would be out of the picture. i have too much respect for guy number one to ever hurt him in any way.

thoughtful answers are appreciated.

9 Answers

Relevance
  • 10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    it sounds to me like you've already answered your own question:)

    you know guy number one is going to be the best for you. But you have to do what makes you happy. nobody on here is gonna know everything about you and the two guys. Which one suits you best? are you looking for a forever? or just a trial run relationship. people can change, but they cant read your mind. IF something guy number 2 does upsets you, tell him. He might surprise you and make the effort to fix it for you. Or he could turn out to be a jerk and hurt you, but more or less what i'm saying is what do you have to lose? you cant go into the relationship thinking he's going to hurt you...you just need to be positive until he gives you a reason to not believe in him. Not to be a sour puss, but everyone is going to have their heart broken in their lifetime. It's a natural thing to experience. I think whichever one you want to be with, you should go for. No matter which one it be, Of course everyone is going to say one, but i'm a risk taker. And i've learned first hand before you can make anyone else in this world happy, you have to make yourself happy. I hope this helps. and good luck girl :)

    Source(s): my opinion!
  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    Go with your heart. You clearly like guy number two, and im sure that you would be more happier with him than you would with guy number one. Yes everybody knows a decent guy, who respects you and treats you right, but who isn't attracted to the 'bad boy' who flirts and teases. Im sure he's only like that because he's currently single, and if he is a deep guy as you say he is, im sure he wouldn't treat you as bad as you think he is. And because you don't want to get hurt in a relationship is not a reason not to be in one. In every relationship, good and bad, you get hurt either way, but its finding the ones that its worth getting hurt for, is the one you really want to be with.

    So definitely guy number 2 :)

    Source(s): Life experience
  • ?
    Lv 5
    10 years ago

    Neither, you can't choose because neither is right for you, if you do end up with one you will probably spend the whole time wandering if it would have been better with the other and wreck a perfectly good relationship and hurt an innocent man who did nothing but catch your eye. Wait for a guy that is so wonderful and amazing that you can't think of anyone else.

  • 10 years ago

    Sometimes we already know the answer. Quality guys don't come around often, 1 gives you what you need, 2 gives you what you want. Look at their history, the choices is obvious but the paradox that women face is trying to choose between their wants and needs. 1 gives you what you need and 2 gives you what you want. We live without wants everyday but we can survive without our needs being fulfilled.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 10 years ago

    All relationships are temporary ranging from one night stands to a long lasting relationships that can endure for fifty years or more...either way, their all just temporary flings of this life.

    When you open your heart to someone you leave it open for them to see everything, and if that be so, then make sure that your significant other can see that you are just a temporary possession as well. Asa lamu alaykum.

  • B.
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    This is what I see:

    Guy #1: He won't ever dump you, you feel more secure with him but he's not the greatest. The reason for this is because he's shy. But you have slight feelings for him...

    Guy #2: You actually like. But you feel you'll get hurt, so you don't see it long term.

    In my opinion, I pick guy #2, because you don't want to hurt the first guy. You barely like him, you just want to feel secure with that guy. Guy #2, you actually like but take the risk because you don't want to play with the first guys feelings, eventually you'll be dumping him.

    B.

  • 10 years ago

    Guy number one sounds better to me,but as you said you know guy number two is the one you want to be with more. guy number one =safety,trust,reliability guy number two= understanding, somewhat geunine and as you said unknown future

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    one

  • 10 years ago

    uno for sure

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.