Ahmad Bradshaw or Frank Gore?

There is no situation where I would ever pick Bradshaw over Gore. Bradshaw is in a RBBC with Jacobs which means he will be competing for carries throughout the year unless Jacobs gets hurt. Then Bradshaw's stock would rise considerably. Gore is the undisputed RB1 in San Fran with Harbaugh already coming out saying that he is going to be the feature back of their offense. Even if Gore gets hurt by mid-season (which happens to him every year), he will still put up better numbers in a half year than Bradshaw will all year barring a Jacobs injury.

I prefer Ahmad Bradshaw even though Brandon Jacobs could vulture some TDs here and there. Gore is a injury risk with that hip and in an offense that is not so great.

Gore. In any setting, RB1, RB2, RB3

I can't imagine a scenario to take Bradshaw over Gore... unless you get points for "rushes inside the 5 yard line and then come out of the game"

EDIT: You know Bradshaw had surgery on his ankles this offseason, right?

definitely gore...he gets every carry for the 49ers while bradshaw gets about 3/4 of the carries since jacobs needs some carries...not to mention gore is just better in general

frank gore gets more carries since thats all the 49ers have

Frank Gore, it's really not close. His team won't matter and you can't control injuries.