Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Allison P asked in TravelCanadaOther - Canada · 10 years ago

Working with someone from a foreign country – how do you deal with the language barrier?

I work in childcare (in a daycare situation) in Canada. The two other ladies I work with are not originally from here. They are both quite new to the country...one of them immigrated from Congo almost a year ago now and the other from India only about 6 months ago. These ladies are both very nice and I love that I am getting the opportunity to work with interesting people of different cultures and backgrounds.

As you can imagine, however, there is somewhat of a language barrier and that's something that I haven't quite adjusted to yet. Although I've been working with these women for about four months now and am slowly getting used to everything language-wise, I still have quite a few issues with it as they both have VERY thick accents and are not AT ALL fluent in english. I am finding that to be quite challenging, as I'm sure anyone would when in any work environment, but it seems like it's especially difficult in the field of work that I am in. We work mostly with very young kids and toddlers. It's not very often that we get kids older than 3 years of age. Most are just learning to talk, and lot of times they don't know what you're saying at the best of times, let alone when the person talking to them is very poor at speaking english. I'm the only childcare worker that speaks their language fluently and as a first language, therefore I am the one having to deal with most of the typical children things like fighting, not sharing toys, tantrums, etc. They have a difficult time communicating with the children. They try, but most often the kids have no clue what they are saying. Sometimes I don't even know what they're saying, let alone a child who is just learning to talk! Like I mentioned, I am the one who has to deal with the not-so-fun aspects of looking after little kids, like when they are throwing a tantrum for example. Sometimes it's easy to calm a child down by distracting them with a toy or something, but a lot of times you have to actually talk a child through it by saying things like “it's okay, calm down, your mom will be back in a few minutes, don't cry, etc etc etc”. These ladies are never sure of what to say to make the child calm down. This also happens when children fight with each other. While they do try, my co-workers cannot ever successfully handle a situation like that because whenever they try to discipline the kids, the kids don't understand what they're saying! For example, when telling the kids to use their manners and say please when they want something, you would normally say “Use your manners! Say please!” The lady from Congo always says “must to speak please” which is fine, but she says it in a VERY thick accent. I have never, in my four months working with her, ever seen a child respond to that phrase when she says it. They just look at her with a blank stare. Whereas when I say “say please!” they immediately do as they're told.

It's even gotten to the point where the parents, when dropping their kids off at daycare, won't even go to the other two with instructions anymore. They'll make a point of waiting until I have a free minute so they can talk to me, even if the others are standing right in front of them empty-handed. I don't mean to make it sound like anybody is racist or anything, because nobody is. The parents will always try to make conversation with the women and everything, but will save the important stuff for me because they don't want anything to get lost in translation, so to speak. When it comes to your child, any parent would want to make sure the daycare workers are fully aware of everything from their eating habits to their sleep patterns. We've had quite a few instances in the past where instructions have been given to the non-english speaking women and they have misunderstood and have wound up making mistakes.

I just find it challenging, because it's always go-go-go-go-go-go for me since I am the only one who knows perfect english. I am the only who can successfully break up fights, console kids who are upset, discipline them, communicate with the parents, etc. I feel like everything always rests on my shoulders, and it's hard for my co-workers to take much of the weight off when they don't understand nor can they communicate well enough to do so. And don't get me wrong, these women are very lovely and pleasant people and I have absolutely nothing against them on a personal level. I feel like the worst person in the world for complaining about this, because it's not their fault at all and I know they're trying, but it's just a bit of a struggle at times. Working with children is my passion, and I wish I could really and fully enjoy my job rather than being stressed all day, ya know?

If anyone has any advice on how to make this situation work better and run more smoothly, I would very much appreciate hearing it! Thanks so much :

4 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    I think your boss hired immigrants because he could get away with paying them less.

    I would go to your boss and tell him you are all for hiring immigrants as long as they can speak the language and while these women speak English they don't speak English any Canadian can understand. Tell him you feel pressured because the parents will only communicate with you, and the kids don't understand what they are saying either, so it is up to you to do all the communicating with parents and kids. Tell him you love your job but every day is a struggle.

    I'm sure there are plenty of places a good child care worker can work. Scout around and see what's available. Then you can tell your boss change things or I'm gone.

    I know how frustrating trying to communicate with people like that. It seems every place you call has Indian or Pakistani people answering phones and often I have to ask to speak to a Canadian because I can't understand a word they say

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    lol your query made me snicker a little bit bit. I'd say Chinese is an overly priceless languge to gain knowledge of too on the grounds that there are plenty of Chinese immigrants within the U.S. as good...However, there are such a large amount of immigrants from such a lot of nations that nearly any language you'll be able to consider of shall be priceless, so what it boils right down to is the language you're all for. Good success

  • 10 years ago

    Talk to your employer and point out the problems. People who work with children need to be understandable - kids learn from them, and no one wants their child to come home with an accent!

  • 10 years ago

    Whoever it is that employs all of you, should be the ones to respond to this. Go to them and tell them the problem, and strongly say its not working. If you are unable to correspond with your work colleagues, it is totally unexceptable.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.