Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Why does Centre ask Modi govt. to ensure security of Bhatt, family?

Earlier HM Mr Chidambaram openly declared that his Ministry would lend any help needed by All India cadre officers in the event of any problem with the state Govt, in obvious reference to Bhatt! Now the officers wife had written to Sonia about a threat to Bhatt and his family! So doors are now open for the Centre to interfere in the case! Isn't it an unprecedented event when the officer has legal avenues to protect himself if at all there was any genuine threat to him!

The officer has been out of duty for several months, obviously figuring out how to fix Modi in the 2002 case where his involvement could not be proved after years of invetigation and prosecution! There has been disciplinary cases against him in the state and the officer took this decision to invite central protection to him from the charges! His once official driver / constable whom he had threatened to sign an affidavit stating he drove the officer to Modi's house during 2002 for a meeting he had allegedly attended (against records to the contrary) had also filed an FIR against the officer of threatening him!

Such an official of dubious background is being openly encouraged by the Centre, more precisely the HM with political motive to slander Modi!

We had heard of opposition govts being dismissed in the past by misusing the Art 356 for flimsy or dubious reasons. But have we heard of the vilificaiton of a CM and the all out efforts to character assasinate him to this level and interfere in the state's role to deal with errant officers?

What are your thoughts on the series of actions against BJP leaders - in Cash for Vote to appointment of Lok Ayuth (of a known anti Modi judge) in Gujarath by the 'Governor', to Bhatt's case?!

Update:

The intemperate personal attacks of a congress activist is unfortunate. Bala had only criticised the stand of some users on the Modi issues, while the antagonist comments personally on the senior citizenship etc of the person and in the same tone talks of Forum decorum. This duplicity is his hall mark through out, whenever his points are strongly refuted he gets worked up.

I don't think Bala or anyone need a apolitical badge to criticise the govt. Democracy includes the opposition who also have sizeable people behind them. Criticism of govt or ruling party is everybody's wish. I also oppose Congress against their wrong policies, the false charges and vilificaiton of BJP, etc not because BJP is holy but their vilification is unjust.

Politics is everybody's subject. And everyone is free to express their points. But getting irritable with others for dissent views and using disrespectful comments is mean.

Update 2:

I know he would react to this also with more rancour, but I shall not reply any more to such rant. I just put in my sympathy to Bala here, since he meant no personal disrespect in disagreeing with views of some people.

I feel that the Centre should have simply forwarded the petition of the woman (Bhatt's wife) to the Chief Secretary of the State for appropriate action, or counselled her to seek court's protection under law. But the invitation of her petition was anticipated when chidambaram publicly hinted at support for All India Service cadres!

When IAS officers like Uma Shankar were harassed in Tamilnadu, this HM never opened his mouth (because DMK was their partner). But even then it would be atrocious to interfere in the State domain unless the case comes up in appeal at the Central Tribunal (not Home dept anyway)!

After all this man refused to interfere in Maoist menace stating that was state subject , which was in serious error as Maoist were not a law and order breakers,

Update 3:

contd.

but terrotists! All perverse stands are taken by this man and his party men come for big support with angry words against critics!

5 Answers

Relevance
  • ezeexs
    Lv 5
    10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Becoz central Govt has nothing else to do......they either try to find ways to corner Modi or save its own men from getting caught by the authorities. Besides this all the central govt activities are put to a sudden halt.....their ministers are just sitting doing nothing.

    Sanjeev Bhatt is a non issue.

  • 10 years ago

    Bhatt is the latest congress tool against Modi. The 1984 riot case is not yet settled.

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    Modi is infamous for murdering people who dared to expose him . He got killed Soharabuddin, Haren Pandya, Ishrat Jahan, Congress MP in Gulbarga Society and thousands of innocent muslims. Sanjiv Bhatt also dared to bring his reality before the world. So, he was arrested on the complain of a junior Policeman. It was all a preplanned move to kill him in Lock up itself. But the Central Government took timely action to protect his life.

  • 10 years ago

    Modi could be a potential contestant for PM post and he is famous across India and beyond for his efficient and clean administration. So Congress and allies (even some BJP allies) are envious of him. They engage in vilification campaign to project him as hardy criminal minded communal person! But the fact that he is accepted by Muslims of Gujarath (in Muslim majority areas too) who had returned him in successive elections clearly dispels the evil propaganda of the Modi antagonists!

    People like GCS or MS cannot fool people by abusing him to any extent. Soharabuddin was a terrorist wanted for several crimes in many States like AP, Maharashtra etc besides Gujarath. He was evading the police for long and there was difficulty in capturing and retaining him in custody also. Because he was earlier arrested under NSA and POTA and managed to get bail (?) and had the audacity to commit further murder in bail period and escape! Such is the “influence” of the criminals in this country So police had most likely taken a risk to finish him in an encounter! It is shameful that the incident is being projected as Modi’s crime against ‘minority’ citizen!

    Even this Bhatt had been under several charges after dept investigations before he made all the accusations on Modi. He found a way out by turning a witness against Modi on 2002 case in order to get support of the Delhi administration (UPA) to escape from the charges suffered from State dept! That he speaks after a decade of the incident and that too after near completion of the SIT enquiry etc was highly suspicious.

    But he Congress leaders in the State and the pro congress outfits started indicting Modi on the dubious charges of Batt. A constable who was his driver during 2002 had also filed a complaint that he was threatened to sign an affidavit supporting his claim that he was present in Modi’s house during the meeting of police officers, while the driver did not drive him to the place at all! But the propaganda is going on and the media also blindly flash these malicious charges of the antagonists!

    So this is all high drama to character assassinate Modi and clear the way for Rahul’s ascendancy to PM post free from strong competitors!

    Edit: Someone is badly screwed up by my comments and engages in abusive objections. But you will all see that I had not told anything wrong. In fact the use of word ''abuse of Modi'' is mild, as the users in reference engage in virtual slander in the lines of Congress leaders (accusing Modi of communalism while not a case has still been proved yet. Of course some people were /are desperately trying to pin him in some way). But then, the antagonists could not brook a ref to their follies. They expose their sick minds by abusing me instead of arguing their sides!

    Edit: How "fairly" the bofors case was conducted and sought to closed is known to the whole country, nay world! Sonia and Manmohan are still to be caught in the net as they are protectng themselves strongly with unverified honesty against strong suspicions of their roles in mega scandals! When more truth comes out, their real faces may be revealed, but even before that Raja is sought to be silenced! But leave their story, nothing from Kargil coffins, Ayodhya to Post godhra is still proved conclusively though new "witnesses" are generated mainly from All India service personnel to pin the opposition!

    I need not learn English at this age particularly from perverts who abuse elders as ''brainless'' (in another post) and here (the post is right here to see) if they could not put plausible response to their rejoinders! I know the straight use of any language known to me and express my honest convictions based on abundant sources I consider reliable! The compulsion with the congress is that they have to project the BJP as communal, inefficient and dangerous so that they do not have an edge in the elections - which may be difficult to carry conviction among people who had seen the real face of the Congress already!

  • I do not find wise to respond to blind BJP activists pretending to a apolitical like Mr. Bala Venkat thus this comments for me are trashed. Not sure at what mental status does an individual start using YA forum to comment on others rather than spending time on answering the real question. Damn it, I wish these self proclaimed apolitical senior citizens learn to be decent on the forum.

    The use of Mr. Pant by state government or to be precise Mr. Modi is clearly evident. If Mr. Pant is to be believe and Mr. Bhatt pressurized him to sign him the affidavit, why did Mr. Pant did not open his mouth and mentioned the same to SIT appointed by supreme court. What assurance of benefit is given to Mr. Pant to file this FIR against Mr. Bhatt.

    Even a kid can understand how Modi and his gang is victimizing every individual who dared to voice against him. All the cases where state government was defending Mr. Bhatt on the grounds of "acted on line of duty" became crime all of a sudden. Is anyone blind?

    Why would central government that is employer of Mr. Bhatt not issue directive to state government? Why are BJP activists getting worked up unless BJP government in State plans to harm Mr. Bhatt? If BJP government in state and tainted Chief Minister does not have any wrong intentions then what is the issue?

    Edit: Oh of course Mr. Bala needs sympathy not only yours but many others. I can send flowers if he is ready to post his address either on the forum or privately as a token of sympathy. Why the hell on earth someone will comment on another user when that user has not even answered unless the user is sick or mentally bankrupt? Or it is fashion to score maximum points on the forum to comment negatively on M.S. on this forum? I am sick and tired form Hippocratic of these users with the mask of "apolitical" and now it is purely give and take. If anyone comment on me he or she will get it back. Its better for users to stick to the subject and answer the question rather than bothering which user supports whom or hates whom. I guess some users even get nightmares of M.S. Actually I am getting afraid that someday I might be accused in court of law for causing cardiac arrest to someone. LoL.

    Edit: Someone needs to learn the meaning of "abusive words", though English is not my first language but I can still help him by sending a dictionary to understand the meaning of "abusive word". And I am not sure if that person really understands if I am screwed or I have screwed him for using my user ID to create a propaganda as usual. Nothing is proved is conveniently used as per comfort by the users with double standards forgetting that they have been accusing and abusing A Raja to Rajiv Gandhi to Sonia Gandhi to Dr Manmohan Singh but nothing has been proved against anyone. But they are lost in Alice in the wonderland. God bless these users with double standards.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.