if the colts dont draft luck or trade there first pick away if they have it they will be the stupidest team?

Indy isn't going to pay Manning and Luck despite what popular opinion is. Because of his injury, the Colts can pay Manning $1,000,000 to go away next year and if they wind up with the top pick I think that's what they'll do. Then Manning, if he can pass a physical, can sign with one of any number of teams that need a decent QB.

Philly might sign him.

This is such a big topic and theres no guarantee that Andrew Luck will be great.. everyone says hes going to be wonderful, but that doesn't mean he will be, heck what if he ended up being the next over hyped qb bust?

No one considers that... evaluating a QB is not exactly a science that guarantees a franchise QB.

I am glad I dont have to make this decision, there isn't a way the colts can do this and please everyone or be right or politically correct whether its dealing Manning, keeping them both or trading away the pick... so I guess I didnt actually answer the Q... I think itd be funny if they dealt manning and he goes on to win a superbowl and luck is a bust...

Yes they will. We all see what happened to the colts this year without manning. Next year, manning will play. Luck (if drafted) will learn from a hall of fame qb. He will be much like aaron rodgers. if they do skip luck, they will pick a rb or a safety. Manning has given the colts permission to draft a qb, so it is very likely they will get Luck.

You Want Andrew Luck to be the Face of the Colts and the NFL.

Make a Halloween Mask out of his Face and see if will not scare people

Luck will need a ton of luck to make a team that bad to win games

If they think Peyton will be there for three or more years, they won't draft him. Too much talent to sit more than a year or two.