Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

The female characters of "Hamlet".?

I am writing a paper on the female characters (Ophelia and Gertrude) of "Hamlet" and I am having trouble answering a question in my paper. The question is the following:

Are the female characters portrayed as weak-minded women that are simply victimized by a patriarchal society, OR are they strong-willed individuals that attempt to take control of their lives?

If you could tell me which one is the case and why the other one is not that would be great. Also if you could tell me some websites to go to to find the information, that would be helpful. I don't want to be handed the information. I just need help on finding where to look.

4 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Well, feminism has obviously failed. I was young when America first started accepting the fact that women could think for themselves and see who is and who isn't strong-wiled, without basing it on gender. 50 years later and you've read the play, but still cannot see strength or weaknesses in women, no matter what kind of society they lived in? Feminism has failed. Bummer. I had hopes it took.

  • 9 years ago

    Just Ophelia for this response. Why not take a closer look at Polonius' admonitions to his son, Laertes. Ophelia is on stage during this moment and of course hears what her father is saying. Is it possible that Polonius is speaking to both his children, not only his son? Is it comprehensible that some of his thoughts are aimed at his daughter and her ill-advised infatuation with the Prince? How does Ophelia respond to the directives that her father offers? There are clues here for her addressing what her father conceives to be an inappropriate attachment. Now, look at the moment in the play where Hamlet insists upon lying in Ophelia's lap (Do you think I meant Country Matters). Is this Ophelia "weak"? Is she in control of her life? Keep in mind that when Hamlet charges that Ophelia get herself to a nunnery, his words have a double meaning: "nunnery" in Shakespeare's times was a euphemism for a brothel. "Neither a borrower nor a lender be" her father tells her. What options are available to her? Does she have a desirable future? Or is her death by drowning not an act of insanity as conceived by many but instead a logical act of a strong-minded woman? After all, she bestows upon others plucked flowers and other signets of nature. It is touching that her gifts are what she is herself: a plucked flower. Before you go this direction too far, explore how suicide is viewed by the Danish society of the 16th century. It was taboo! If Ophelia chooses her own death, she is indeed a strong-willed woman, one not of her own times but of times that were yet to be. To proclaim or dismiss Ophelia as weak-minded or victimized by the men in her life demeans who she really was.

    Source(s): Years of study.
  • Sheree
    Lv 6
    9 years ago

    It's an interesting questions and I would say that both women are strong on some levels and very weak on others. Let's take a look at Ophelia first:

    Ophelia is more of weak person than a strong one. Although she affirms her feelings for Hamlet and argues with her brother Laertes and father Polonius about it, she did allow Hamlet to have sex with her (something that would have made her seem ruined, as being a virgin at marriage was important) this is perhaps could be argued as a weakness, however it could also be argued that it was her decision. Ophelia also ends up insane and dead, if anything tells us how weak she was, it is this.

    Hamlet's mother Gertrude is more complex. Her marriage to Claudius was for political reasons, it was the keep the country running and Hamlet's family ruling. To keep their line going. It could be argued that this was a strong decision to make, and I would certainly argue that it was, as it put her relationship with her son at risk. She did it because she felt that it was neceassry. However she is weak in many other aspects, she does not reassure her son, she allows Claudius to take charge and submits to him. She chooses Political over Domestic. However at the end of the play she does indeed choose her son. In the final scene she changes 'our son' to 'my son'. She wants Hamlet to win the sword fight. She chooses her son (Domestic) over Political (Claudius) and therefore this shows her eventual strength, but she also ends up dead from being poisoned to the very man to whom she submitted to.

    Source(s): From when I studied Hamlet. Go carefully through the play and find quotes to back up the arguement, also try using Spark Notes which are helpful. However reading through throughly and annotating is always most helpful.
  • Anonymous
    4 years ago

    nicely, the female characters in maximum shonen are greater no longer worry-free and undesirable a** that's a sturdy factor, yet they often finally end up being to sexualized that's stressful so i desire shojo lady characters. As for adult males, i like shonen adult males via fact they are actually not worry-free and have sturdy personalities and could often do super-cool issues. Shojo adult males are in basic terms warm and candy. i think the two are the two sturdy. :}

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.