Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Do CHP (California Highway Patrol) Officers need to read you your Miranda Rights?
As the question asks, do CHP Officers have to read your miranda rights when arresting you?
7 Answers
- davidmi711Lv 79 years agoFavorite Answer
It is not a requirement that an officer read you your rights when you are arrested unless the officer is going to ask you question about the alleged crime after you are in custody. Even if the officer fails to do so the only thing that will happen is the answers you provided can be excluded as evidence in court. This does not include identifying information.
- Michael HLv 79 years ago
Miranda rights need only be read to you if...
a) you are under arrest or detained
AND
b) the officer intends to question you regarding the alleged crime.
So the answer is no, not like on television, they do not need to read you your rights when arresting you. If they have all the evidence they need, they need not read them to you at all.
- 9 years ago
Before asking you questions if you are in custody (not free to leave), they must read you your rights. If it is made clear that you can leave any time you want, then there is no such requirement.
If you are not properly read your rights, the result is NOT a dismissal of your case - it is only means that the statements cannot be used against you. though if they have other evidence of the crime, you can still be charged.
- tonalc2Lv 79 years ago
No officer "needs to" read you your rights when you are arrested.
The only result of their not being read to you would be that anything you said could not be used against you in court.
- STEVEN FLv 79 years ago
NO ONE has to read you your rights when arresting you. Reading your rights is ONLY required before QUESTIONING you about a crime in which you are a suspect. Even then, the most tat happens if they don't read your rights is that they can't use any ANSWERS you give against you in court. They CAN use any statements you make WITHOUT being questioned against you.
tonalc2 is not entirely correct. ONLY answers to questions are excluded if you are not read your rights. 'Spontaneous declarations' are still admissible.
- 9 years ago
yes. duh, they are officers. all law enforcement officers must Mirandize you when arresting you. if they don't you can use that as a defence in court.